Taming inflation in China, Brazil, and IndiaJanuary 5, 2011: 11:47 AM ET
The Fed's quantitative easing will likely lead to rising inflation in these three important countries. With food prices already skyrocketing, how well will their central bankers tame the beast?
by Darius Dale, Hedgeye
Chairman Bernanke's experiment with quantitative easing continues to have unintended consequences for the global economy, due to the impact of the equation highlighted below:
QE2 = inflation [globally] = monetary policy tightening [globally] = slower growth [globally]
A brief review of global economic data points highlights struggles with inflation in three very key countries: China, India and Brazil. While the divergence between each country's response reminds us that both inflation and monetary policy are local, analyzing them collectively allows us to derive the equation laid out above.
Let's briefly visit each country's headlines and data points from today's global macro run for a quick update on the global inflation front.
Policy Stance: Proactive
On a relative basis, China has been particularly proactive in its fight with inflation of late, hiking interest rates twice in the last 2.5 months, raising banks' reserve requirements, and announcing potential price controls and supply rationing in its food market. China has proactively fought speculation and its latest Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) report shows early signs of success.
Manufacturing PMI, a proxy for demand, slowed in December to 53.9 vs. 55.2 prior with the Input Prices component backing off a 29-month high, coming in at 66.7 vs. 73.5 in November. Dampening some of the positive headway made in the report was an acceleration in Non-Manufacturing PMI to 56.5 vs. 53.2 prior, which suggests Chinese monetary policy has more tightening to do before growth has slowed enough to rein in both inflation and inflation expectations.
We continue to have conviction that growth is slowing and inflation will remain a headwind in China over the intermediate term, necessitating more tightening measures which are likely to have an incremental drag on Chinese (and therefore global) GDP growth. Chinese Central Bank Governor Zhou Xiaochuan agrees, pledging last week to shift Chinese monetary policy to a "prudent" stance in order to tackle inflation in the New Year.
Policy Stance: Reactive
Last fall, Brazil's monetary policy graded out less than favorably due to its relatively late reaction (compared to China) in fighting inflation. But it appears Brazil is finally ready to shift the fight into high gear in January, after raising reserve requirements early last month. Analysis of Brazilian interest rate swaps suggests traders are betting incoming Central Bank President Alexandre Tombini will hike the benchmark Selic rate by 50bps to 11.25% in his first meeting as chief on January 18-19.
New President Dilma Rousseff, who only recently brought about widespread concern in the Brazilian bond market because of the perception that she would fail to contain inflation, is joining in on the fight, pledging to cut government spending by $15 billion – a sum that exceeded investor expectations. Last weekend, she also pledged to tackle the "plague" of inflation:
"To ensure the continuation of the current economic growth cycle we need to ensure stability, especially price stability… We won't allow under any hypothesis that this plague returns to eat away our economic tissue and hurt the poorest families."
The hope is that she's willing to back her rhetoric with prudent policy action, and to some extent, she's shown signs of this. On the flip side, however, we see that the Brazilian Congress just approved an increase in the minimum salary – a metric that determines both the nation's minimum wage and transfer payments. For reference, the last adjustment to the Bolsa Familia program was a 10% increase in 2009.
Given that a broad-based wage hike would augment already-robust Brazilian consumer demand, we would expect to see more monetary policy tightening and offsetting fiscal restraint elsewhere in the government's budget over the intermediate term.
Elsewhere on the demand front, we see Brazil's Manufacturing PMI came in at 52.4 for December, a 2.5 increase over November's 49.9 reading. Brazil is in a setup very similar to China: while we have conviction that growth will continue to slow throughout the first half of 2011, it is robust enough to continue providing demand-side inflationary pressures.
Brazil's CPI (as measured by the unofficial FGV IGP-M Index) accelerated in December to grow by 11.32% year-over-year, driven by higher food prices that are now consuming one-third of poor Brazilian's incomes. By comparison, the Benchmark ICPA Index accelerated to a 21-month high in November, coming in at +5.63% YoY.
Policy Stance: Inactive
India continues to lag in its bout with taming inflation, opting instead for the "wait and see" approach with regard to implementing another round(s) of tightening. Having shifted from his hawkish stance (six rate hikes in 2010) to a more relaxed position, Reserve Bank of India Governor Duvvuri Subarrao has held true to his November promise that additional rate hikes are not in India's near-term future.
That would be fine if India had inflation under control. Unfortunately, the latest wholesale price index (WPI) reading of +7.5% year-over-year suggests India is far from achieving its target of +4-4.5% inflation. It is, however, a marginal improvement nonetheless, though expecting an additional +300bps drop from here absent any further tightening would be reckless at best. Moreover, food inflation continues to plague the 828 million Indians who live on less than $2 per day, with the PPP accelerating to +14.44% year-over-year in the second week of December.
Compounding this blatant lack of vigilance is the RBI's decision to add fuel to the fire by buying back government bonds from Indian lenders with the intention of increasing liquidity in a cash-strapped banking system that has been struggling to meet demand for loans. In December, the RBI pumped nearly 414 billion rupees ($9.3B) into India's financial system via sovereign bond purchases (a.k.a. Quantitative Easing).
Fueling speculation when inflation is running at nearly twice the target rate is not our idea of prudent monetary policy. We expect further tightening ahead, but only after inflation becomes the problem it was in the first half of 2010. For this reason, we continue to remain bearish on Indian equities over the intermediate-term trend. We are, however, bullish on many commodities (corn, sugar, oil, etc.) as countries like China and India look to accelerate food and energy imports to ease any supply shortages that are perpetuating rising prices in their economies.
Also on Fortune.com: