Fighting debt: How the U.S. is doing it better

April 24, 2014: 4:59 PM ET

GDP growth has been greater than average interest rates -- a big reason why America's economy has outperformed many of its industrialized neighbors.

By Monty J. Bennett

Crushing debt

Crushing debt

FORTUNE -- Throughout the U.S. recovery we've seen economic data bounce in peaked highs and lows. Real GDP growth since the financial crisis has been as high as nearly 5% year over year and as low as 0%. I expect the sluggish and volatile recovery to continue for years to come. Why? In one word: deleveraging.

The U.S. economy has been going through a deleveraging not seen since the Great Depression. Back then, total debt reached 300% of GDP. It continued to drop over the next two decades to 150% of GDP before rising again in the early 1950s.

The deleveraging of the Great Depression was accomplished thanks to a combination of household austerity, inflation, and government stimulus. Household austerity occurred thanks to elevated savings rates along with pay-downs and defaults on debt during the 1930s while rationing to support the war effort had similar effects in the 1940s. Additionally, breaking away from the gold standard helped raise prices and therefore reduced the real value of America's debt. Lastly, the government spending from various New Deal schemes to the vast mobilization during WWII contributed to keeping total GDP growth positive.

MORE: Time to rethink sanctions against Russia and aid to Ukraine

The deleveraging that we are going through today is much improved from the volatile economic outcomes experienced during the Depression. Most of the deleveraging since the Great Recession has occurred in households, mostly in the form of mortgages (which fell from 73% of GDP in 2008 to 55% of GDP today), and across the U.S. financial sector (where debtfell from 118% of GDP in 2008 to 82% of GDP today).

Conversely, the federal government leveraged up (with debts rising from 72% of GDP in 2008 to 102% of GDP today) to offset this decline in borrowing from households and the financial sector. The other major sources of debt (non-financial corporate, state & local government, consumer credit, and foreign borrowing) have remained largely unchanged from crisis levels. So overall, the decline in debt-to-GDP has been relatively muted so far, falling from 409% of GDP in 2008 to 392% of GDP today.

Nonetheless, the U.S. has experienced better outcomes, especially when compared to Europe and Japan because it is keeping the combination of austerity, inflation, and defaults as balanced as possible, while keeping nominal GDP growth above the general interest rates in the economy. The fact that nominal GDP growth is greater than average interest rates is a prerequisite for a well-handled deleveraging, and it is one reason why U.S. economic performance, while choppy, has outperformed many of its industrialized peers.

MORE: What's driving the buyout comeback?

Europe, for example, has seen its GDP growth contract in recent years while in many cases the benchmark lending rates exploded higher. This has resulted in debt-to-GDP ratios actually continuing to climb since 2008 in much of the Euro area. Japan has also seen its debt-to-GDP ratios climb consistently since the early 1990s despite having the lowest interest rates in the developed world. This has occurred because deflation has kept nominal GDP growth below even their extremely low interest rates.

Europe's poor economic results have occurred thanks in part to a disjointed relationship between monetary and fiscal policy. The Maastricht Treaty puts limits on federal budget deficits in Europe while the absence of a unified treasury makes monetary policy (QE policies in particular) difficult to administer. Let's hope for their sake (and ours) that they follow through with their recent statements about being more accommodative if necessary.

Japan has also gotten its policy responses incorrect following their debt build-up and financial crisis. While Japan had the same monetary and fiscal policy tools as the U.S. government (but not the Europeans), they generally lacked a sense of urgency to their policy responses in the early years after their crisis in the early 1990s. Japan's government, in error, delivered policies as if its economy was in a typical business cycle slump. After years of languishing with sub-par growth, "Abenomics," Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's three-pronged approach to jump-starting the economy, could represent a turning point for Japan's economy. Time will tell if these bold policies will restore consistent growth and ultimately push nominal GDP growth above their interest rates.

MORE: For some U.S. states, budget woes are on the horizon

So should we just ignore the economic data? Of course not. Just be prepared for continued economic reports that don't look that bad or that great. Don't get worked up over one month or one quarter of soft data. The environment we are going through today is unlike the business cycles that most of us have grown familiar with over our careers. While robust growth is unlikely to materialize in the near future, we can be confident that a policy-driven recession is also unlikely to occur. Absent some external shock, we are likely to continue to muddle through for the next several years. Be thankful that our policymakers, especially at the Federal Reserve, have accurately diagnosed the patient and are doing their best to accommodate this deleveraging process.

"Monty J. Bennett is Chairman and CEO of Dallas-Based Ashford Hospitality Trust and Ashford Hospitality Prime, as well as CIO of Ashford Investment Management, a real estate focused investment management company."  Follow him @MBennettAshford

  • Coca-Cola's equity plan: Did shareholders say yes, or no?

    Coke says 83% approved the manager compensation plan, but the numbers don't add up.

    By Paul Hodgson

    FORTUNE -- Although Coca-Cola's (KO) controversial equity compensation plan was apparently approved by a majority of shareholders at the company's annual meeting in Atlanta this week, it appears to be a half-hearted approval.

    Under the plan, Coke's managers are to be paid generously with company shares if they achieve specific performance goals. Critics have said the plan would dilute MORE

    Apr 24, 2014 4:18 PM ET
  • Health care M&A activity hits record level

    It's been a huge week for health care M&A, putting 2014 on a record pace.

    FORTUNE -- The year-to-date level of announced M&A activity in the health care sector is at its highest level since Thomson Reuters (TRI) began tracking such deals in 1980, hitting $153.5 billion. Approximately 71% of that volume is in the pharmaceutical sector, followed by health care equipment and technology.

    If this isn't something you really saw coming, that's probably MORE

    - Apr 24, 2014 12:39 PM ET
    Posted in: ,
  • GM posts huge profit drop driven by ignition switch crisis

    No. 1 U.S. automaker reports its worst quarterly results since emerging from bankruptcy.

    By Doron Levin

    FORTUNE -- General Motors (GM) posted a scant $125 million first-quarter profit Thursday, an 86% drop from its profit in the same quarter one year ago, as its earnings were dented by the massive cost of an ignition-switch recall crisis, as well as losses overseas.

    It was GM's worst quarterly result since emerging from bankruptcy.

    The No. 1 U.S. MORE

    Apr 24, 2014 12:18 PM ET
  • One step backward for corporate accountability

    A bill before Congress would eliminate a requirement that almost all public companies release earnings in an openly accessible, machine-readable format called XBRL.

    By Ethan Rouen

    FORTUNE -- It was supposed to be the great democratizer in financial information.

    Without a pricey subscription to a data service like Bloomberg or Capital IQ, with eXtensible Business Reporting Language (XBRL), even the smallest investor would be able to access and analyze company financial results the instant they MORE

    Apr 24, 2014 12:05 PM ET
  • Are enterprise tech VC valuations on their way down?

    VC valuations for enterprise tech startups have been rising for years. But things are beginning to change.

    FORTUNE -- The private markets typically follow the public markets on the way up, and also follow them on the way down. And that seems to be what we're seeing when it comes to venture capital deals for enterprise software companies.

    Take a look at the recent stock performance of some of VC-backed enterprise software companies MORE

    - Apr 24, 2014 11:42 AM ET
    Posted in:
  • Time to rethink sanctions against Russia and aid to Ukraine

    Russia seems undeterred by sanctions, and the latest efforts to create a truce are failing.

    By Robert Kahn

    FORTUNE -- As the crisis in Ukraine intensified on Thursday with the reported deaths of up to five pro-Russian militants, it's obvious the Obama administration's economic strategy for supporting Ukraine isn't working.

    Mild economic sanctions, coupled with the threat of more to come, are imposing an economic price on Russia, but it's not enough to MORE

    Apr 24, 2014 10:41 AM ET
  • Deals of the day: Biomet sold for $13 billion

    To get deals in your inbox each morning, sign up for our Term Sheet newsletter

    Venture Capital Deals

    Crispr Therapeutics, a Swiss developer of gene-editing technology, has raised $25 million in Series A funding from Versant Ventures. ShopKeep POS, a New York-based provider of cloud-based point-of-sale solutions for retailers,, has raised $25 million in Series C funding. Thayer Street Partners led the round, and was joined by return backers Canaan Partners, TTV Capital and Tribeca Venture Partners. Bitmoon MORE

    - Apr 24, 2014 10:35 AM ET
  • When Apple's Tim Cook didn't like stock splits

    Apple is doing something Tim Cook once said "does nothing."

    FORTUNE -- Apple (AAPL)  just announced that it will do a 7-1 stock split, alongside an increased dividend (to 8%) and an increased stock buyback (from $60 billion to $90 billion).

    Who could object to such a thing? Well, except for a past incarnation of Apple CEO Tim Cook.

    During a shareholder meeting in February 2012, Cook was asked about why Apple wasn't doing MORE

    - Apr 23, 2014 4:52 PM ET
    Posted in: ,
  • Buffett: Coke exec compensation plan was excessive

    Coca-Cola's controversial executive compensation plan passed at Coke's annual meeting, but without Buffett's help.

    FORTUNE -- Warren Buffett called Coca-Cola's (KO) controversial compensation plan excessive, but said he declined to vote against it.

    The plan -- which will pay Coke managers generously with shares of the company if they achieve specific performance goals -- passed on Wednesday at Coke's annual meeting, but without Buffett's help. Buffett said he abstained in the vote. Berkshire Hathaway (BRKA), Buffett's insurance MORE

    - Apr 23, 2014 4:22 PM ET
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.