By Jack T. Ciesielski
FORTUNE -- Costless stock options. Lending to subprime borrowers. The irrelevance of earnings and cash flow for Internet companies because they can always tap capital markets. Those are some of the good ideas gone bad on Wall Street, all seemingly foolproof at first. Costless stock options warped earnings and investor expectations for years until accountants forced their cost into financial reporting. Subprime lending was corrected by a financial crisis costing taxpayers billions. Internet companies? We know how those turned out.
The international tax game might also make the list of good ideas gone bad. Governments keep losing revenues while still providing services as U.S. companies dodge taxes on foreign earnings, but that can't last forever.
The cumulative untaxed foreign earnings for 322 of the 500 companies listed in the Standard & Poor's Index reached $2 trillion at the end of 2013, with $530 billion tucked inside 57 technology companies and another $426 billion in 43 health care companies, according to figures compiled by R.G. Associates. It's an incredible amount of potential tax base for governments around the world to lose, but those losses appear to be waning. Some technology firms -- Apple (AAPL) and Google (GOOG) among them -- showed year-to-year declines in the estimated amount of untaxed foreign earnings, according to R.G. Associates. In fact, the entire technology and health care sectors showed declines compared to 2012, suggesting firms may be seeing the handwriting on the wall as governments look to coordinate efforts to fix problems plaguing international taxation.
Clever international corporate tax management has many troubling aspects. For one thing, only those firms whose primary assets are intangible and portable play the tax management game well. The obvious beneficiaries are firms in the technology and health care sectors, whose prime assets are intellectual property; those at a disadvantage are firms whose primary operating assets are domestically embedded. (When did you last hear of a railroad taking advantage of international tax laws?) Another troublesome aspect is that the perennial drone of the news media about the unfairness of light corporate tax bills corrodes the confidence of all taxpayers, subtly persuading them that cheating is a good idea.
The problem is that the world's governments have not been effective at keeping tax laws relevant in today's economy, while corporate tax management has evolved several generations beyond. Some aspects of international tax treaties have their origins in the 1920s, like requiring a permanent business establishment in a country so that it may be taxed by that country's government. In today's world, a company can do business anywhere without establishing permanence by conducting trade over the Internet.
A unilateral action by just one country won't fix its problem, because it could be offset by another country's actions. While cooperation among countries is an elusive thing, it's not impossible. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has been aggressively developing proposals to address tax base erosion and international profit shifting. The OECD has moved surprisingly fast, developing a 15-step "action plan" that it expects to complete by December 2015, with major parts to be completed by this fall. The goal is to provide guidance and methods for countries to change their tax laws in a coordinated fashion and bring them into the 21st century.
Proposals to fix international taxation on a cooperative basis are one thing; writing tax laws in the U.S. by Congress is quite another. The OECD's plans for revising international tax treaties and taxation principles won't automatically change any country's laws, much less those of the United States. Yet if the OECD is successful in creating a model of coordinated tax policies, tax regimes might be established globally, making it harder for one country to go it alone. Congressional tax writers pay attention to the OECD's efforts and might incorporate some of their thinking as various tax proposals evolve.
The weaning process may well be under way.
Jack T. Ciesielski is president of R.G. Associates, Inc., an asset management and research firm in Baltimore that publishes The Analyst's Accounting Observer, a research service for institutional investors.
As the economy recovers, here are five ways to steer your company on the path toward long-term growth
By Cesare Mainardi
FORTUNE – As the fog of economic uncertainty is finally lifting, many companies are approaching a critical turning point. Unfortunately, the fight to survive the Great Recession brought out the worst in far too many boardrooms. Companies slashed costs and cut head count. Investments in new employees and equipment slowed MOREMar 18, 2014 11:50 AM ET
Why are we so fascinated by the man missing from the center of bitcoin? Our need to know reveals a desire for geniuses, leaders -- and authority.
By David Z. Morris
FORTUNE -- "I am not Dorian S. Nakamoto."
That was the simple message posted from an account on the website of the Peer to Peer Foundation at 10 p.m. ET Thursday. The message was posted from an account under MOREMar 7, 2014 10:51 AM ET
It could build its own driverless electric car and stay ahead of the competition for years to come.
By Mike Kwatinetz
FORTUNE -- When Facebook (FB) acquired WhatsApp last week for $19 billion, it set itself apart from earlier generation technology leaders like Apple (AAPL) and Microsoft (MSFT). Facebook has decided that it wants to own the social space now, as well as in the future, and is willing to pay an MOREMar 3, 2014 8:45 AM ET
Why the market jolt last week was the start of a sobering reality check for tech stocks.
FORTUNE -- Market prognosticators have conjured up many a reason for the two-day rout of stocks on Thursday and Friday, which sent the Dow Jones Industrial Average (INDU) plunging 494 points (3%) and the S&P 500 (SPX) down 55 points (3%). Some blamed the slowdown in China's perpetual manufacturing machine; others, the fears of MOREShawn Tully, senior editor-at-large - Jan 27, 2014 5:00 AM ET
Corporate America needs to step up and pay its fair share, instead of using shareholder value as an excuse to dodge taxes.
FORTUNE -- At first glance, you would think that the CEOs of taxophobic U.S. corporations and our less-than-stellar leaders in Washington have nothing in common. But you'd be wrong. What they share is a lack of shame and an excess of narrow thinking.
The similarity between C-suite tax avoiders and MOREAllan Sloan, senior editor-at-large - Oct 30, 2013 5:00 AM ET
What Carl Icahn wants from Apple.
FORTUNE -- Carl Icahn this morning launched his new website, which includes a letter to Apple (AAPL) CEO Tim Cook.
In it, Icahn details how he has increased his stake in Apple to 4.73 million shares (valued at around $2.5 billion, with plans to buy more), and how he remains convinced that the company should launch a $150 billion share buyback. Icahn also takes great care MOREDan Primack - Oct 24, 2013 9:54 AM ET
Activist investors are getting more powerful and more determined than ever to take on the managements of public companies. The surprise is just how giant that prey has become.
By Geoff Colvin, senior editor-at-large
FORTUNE -- Talk candidly with corporate directors and they'll tell you their No. 1 worry is no longer the economy or the chance of an accounting scandal -- it's activist investors. That's because activists have taken on MORESep 23, 2013 5:00 AM ET
Decelerating investment in housing, infrastructure and manufacturing, is dragging on incomes.
By John Foley, Reuters Breakingviews
FORTUNE -- Consumer brands in China are finding their rewards aren't quite as advertised. Growth in purchases of a wide range of goods has slowed sharply over the past year, and companies ranging from Samsonite to Apple (AAPL) are reporting disappointing Chinese sales figures. Consumers in the world's second-largest economy will have their day, but the MOREAug 30, 2013 9:30 AM ET
Activist makes his next big tech move.
FORTUNE -- Earlier this week Carl Icahn told us to watch his Twitter feed. Now we know why:
No word yet on exactly how many Apple (AAPL) shares Icahn holds, or what Cook's response was to Icahn's overture. Apple stock had been relatively flat before Icahn's tweets, but by 2:50pm was up more than $17 per share (3.66%). For the year, Apple is down more MOREDan Primack - Aug 13, 2013 2:28 PM ET
|GM's recalled Cobalt was a failure from the start|
|General Mills reverses course on right to sue after backlash|
|Pope Francis challenges the free market - The Buzz|
|Stocks: It's report card time on Wall Street|
|Your Internet security relies on a few volunteers|