commercial real estate

Why the commercial real estate crash never came

September 23, 2013: 11:44 AM ET

After the housing market collapsed, many economists predicted a similar fate for commercial real estate. Here's why it never happened.

hilton-hotel-sign-620xaFORTUNE -- Hilton Worldwide recently announced plans to return to the public market, after The Blackstone Group (BX) took the hotel giant private in 2007.

The private equity firm is eager to recoup some of the $26 billion it paid for the chain just before the credit crunch. Whether Blackstone will be successful remains to be seen, but the initial public offering comes as the hotel industry, and more broadly, the commercial real estate market, turns around.

Less than four years ago, lawmakers and executives warned that the market for hotels, malls, apartments, and office buildings would be the next to collapse, after countless homeowners lost their homes to foreclosures. While prices across commercial real estate declined almost 40%, it never quite crashed like the housing market. Yes there were foreclosures and defaults, but not to the scale of housing.

There are a few reasons why the crash never came, which also help explain how commercial real estate has recovered much faster than the market for homes. Unlike residential, the commercial market didn't bubble up nearly as much as housing; it was not nearly as overbuilt, either.

MORE: The barbarians are still at the gate

This had a lot to do with timing, says Casey Mulligan, economics professor at the University of Chicago. The boom in home construction took workers, materials, and land away from the commercial sector. It was only after 2005, when the housing market bubble burst, that more of these resources freed up and construction projects started picking up -- but that was short-lived since the financial crisis shortly followed.

While there were defaults, the commercial market didn't see nearly as many foreclosures as the housing market. Joblessness and plummeting home prices led many to miss mortgage payments, which led to the wave of defaults. Commercial properties saw similar price declines, but unlike residential properties, owners enjoyed continuous flow of income by way of rents from tenants. This gave owners struggling with the credit crunch considerable relief.

"There were defaults in the commercial space, but it didn't hit the heights seen in the single-family market," says Susan Wachter, real estate and finance professor at the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School of Business. Rather than a wave of defaults, the real estate crash triggered a wave of workouts whereby banks renegotiated the terms of loans, sold to new owners or took the properties over. Private equity firms also swooped in and bought up distressed properties.

"Any solution did not trigger excess supply in the market," Wachter adds. "It was almost a nonevent in the commercial space."

MORE: More Americans pay mortgage first again, then credit cards

On average, prices regained all the ground that was lost during the downturn, according to the monthly index by Green Street Advisors that tracks commercial real estate prices. While office industrial buildings have a ways to go, prices for apartments, high-end malls, and strip centers are well above their prior peak.

Hotels, in particular, have recovered in big ways as stocks soar and the economy improves. And Hilton's move to go public is the latest example. With hotel stocks close to a five-year high and revenue and profits growing industry-wide, investors are taking advantage of the stock rally to sell assets.

Hyatt Hotels (H), the chain controlled by Chicago's Pritzker family, raised $1.09 billion in an IPO in 2009; it rose 12% on its first day of trading. Since the IPO, shares have gained 77%.

Caesars Entertainment (CZR), the casino chain that also operates hotels, sold shares to the public last year, after private-equity owners Apollo Global Management LLC and TPG Capital took the company private about four years ago. Since the IPO, shares have risen 81%.

The crash in commercial real estate may or may not have happened, but if it did, it probably wasn't as bad as many thought.

  • Why are the Chinese investing in Toledo?

    Faced with a looming real estate bubble in their home country, speculators from China are turning to Middle America.

    By Graham Webster, contributor

    FORTUNE -- In March 2011, Chinese investors paid $2.15 million cash for a restaurant complex on the Maumee River in Toledo, Ohio. Soon they put down another $3.8 million on 69 acres of newly decontaminated land in the city's Marina District, promising to invest $200 million in a MORE

    Jun 20, 2012 8:45 AM ET
  • Why commercial real estate is still a gamble

    The forecasts are rosy for the CRE market, but systemic headwinds still exist, making this a tough sector to bank on profits.

    By Kit R. Roane, contributor

    Until recently, the smart money saw commercial real estate as the next asset class to do a number on the economy. Now some believe it is turning into a feather in the recovery's cap. But every bet has its risks -- and in this case, MORE

    Jan 3, 2011 2:04 PM ET
  • Riding the unlikely commercial real estate rebound

    For years commercial real estate has been billed as the next big train wreck. So why are some investors shouting all aboard?

    A slowly recovering economy is part of it, though no one expects to make a quick killing on loans and securities tied to office buildings, hotels, shopping malls and the like. The bigger drivers of this rally are the low rates pushing investors to reach for yield by taking on MORE

    - Dec 20, 2010 6:41 AM ET
  • Update: S&P warns on commercial real estate

    Commercial real estate worries aren't just for banks any more.

    Standard & Poor's downgraded three insurance companies, including Principal Financial (PFG), citing expected losses on commercial mortgages and commercial mortgage-backed securities, or CMBS.

    Thursday's downgrades come after an industry-wide review led the rating agency to focus on "several U.S. life companies with significant exposure to commercial mortgages and CMBS relative to total invested assets or potential losses relative to capital under stress MORE

    - May 13, 2010 11:32 AM ET
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by WordPress.com VIP.