debt crisis

El-Erian: Cautious optimism about Greece's return to capital markets

April 3, 2014: 10:29 AM ET

Renewed access to financing must not divert the debt-troubled nation from implementing critical economic reforms.

By Mohamed A. El-Erian


FORTUNE -- The Greek Government caused quite a stir this week when it announced it would soon re-enter the international capital markets. Rightly so. It is a big deal for a sovereign to be able to place its first voluntary bond issuance after having undergone a debt restructuring that imposed considerable losses on investors and shut voluntary access to private capital financing.

With the overall unemployment rate at 27%, and with youth joblessness at 58%, few are daft enough to confuse Greece's likely return to voluntary market funding with an all clear sign on the economy. However, the risk is elsewhere -- that the renewed availability of private financing will defer rather than support the yet-to-be-completed economic reform effort.

Renewed market access is a direct consequence of the multi-year efforts Greece has made in overcoming its massive financial imbalances, as well as enormous backing from European neighbors and the International Monetary Fund.

MORE: How to reform Ukraine's economy

Like others, the country is also benefiting from a notable, albeit less sustainable, market phenomenon -- namely, a seemingly insatiable investor appetite for the "down in quality" bond trade in search of increasingly scarce yield.

Having said that, we should remember that it took over six months for the Greek government to finally reach agreement with its official creditors on the release of delayed funding under the country's second international bailout package. In the process, some policy measures were deferred; others only partially implemented.

Given the protracted negotiations, the government is not very enthusiastic about negotiating a new package. If anything, the temptation is to use the renewed availability of private bond financing to reduce dependence on official funding and, in the process, dilute outsiders' policy conditionality that comes with that.

There are three big reasons why such a course of action would likely prove short-sighted for Greece; and it would also expose new bond investors to risks down the road.

First, notwithstanding the massive decline in market yields on Greek securities, the level at which the government would likely borrow these days (around 7%) is still above what would be deemed safe in terms of debt sustainability. It is also a multiple of what it pays on loans from official creditors.

MORE: Crimea poses threat to tourism in Spain, Greece

Second, the existing stock of Greek debt remains uncomfortably high. It is also less flexible now that its composition has shifted markedly in favor of more senior, and therefore harder to restructure, official debt (including considerable obligations to the European Central Bank and the IMF).

Third, economic growth remains anemic, depriving Greece from the one remedy that allows debtors to improve living standards while also dealing with legacy obligations.

Greece still has quite a way to go before it can decisively emerge from a crisis that has caused havoc, impoverished millions of citizens, and caused many others to migrate in search of a better life. It would be a tragedy if its impending return to international capital markets were to serve as an excuse to delay the required reforms.

Mohamed A. El-Erian, former CEO and co-CIO of PIMCO, is a member of the International Executive Committee at Allianz and chief economic advisor to its management board, chair of the President's Global Development Council, and author of the NYT/WSJ bestseller When Markets Collide. Follow him on Twitter @elerianm.

  • Why the stock market will yawn at the sequester

    Profits have been relatively resilient during the decline in government spending over the past few years. Can that continue with the massive cuts coming?

    FORTUNE -- Despite all the doomsday-like scenarios we've heard that budget cuts could wreak havoc on the U.S. economy, investors won't likely sweat it – at least not in the short-term.

    To be sure, the cuts are indeed very deep. If Congress fails to strike a budget deal MORE

    - Feb 27, 2013 11:23 AM ET
  • How Tim Geithner can dodge the next debt crisis

    An open letter to Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner on how to avoid the fiscal cliff: Stop acting like a policy wonk and start acting like a Wall Street dealmaker.

    FORTUNE -- Dear Mr. Secretary:

    I know that even though President Obama has been reelected, you are planning to leave the Treasury. So I'd like to offer you a goodbye gift. It's not money or a prestigious seven-digit-a-year gig. It's a way to MORE

    - Nov 14, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • A world in chaos? That may be a good thing.

    Outrage is the word for 2012. Hopefully there's enough out there to solve some giant problems that have been festering for far too long.

    By Geoff Colvin, senior editor-at-large

    FORTUNE -- Too much is happening in the world. Politically, economically, and culturally momentous news is occurring on every continent seemingly every day, and it's overwhelming for the hapless citizen striving to stay on top of it all. If you want to impose MORE

    Jan 23, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • The Eurozone crisis will not go away until banks face reality

    European regulators have turned risk assessment into an insider's game where the bankers are calling the shots.

    By Sheila Bair, contributor

    FORTUNE -- The European sovereign debt crisis is slowly driving the global economy back into the ditch. Why is this crisis so unresolvable? The answer comes back once again to excess risk taking and leverage in the banking sector. In late October, Europe's leaders finally persuaded the banks to take a 50% MORE

    Nov 2, 2011 5:00 AM ET
  • Europe's debt crisis: Expect more trouble

    If eurozone leaders can't get ahead of the current crisis, instead of just plugging holes, they'll never find a solution.

    By Shriti Vadera, contributor

    FORTUNE -- The bailout agreement reached this summer to stop Europe's downward spiral did not even buy time for its sacrosanct August holidays. Within two weeks of the pact, a reluctant European Central Bank was forced to step into the breach and buy Italian and Spanish bonds to MORE

    Aug 19, 2011 5:00 AM ET
  • 8 banks fail Europe's stress test

    European regulators said 8 banks will need 2.5 billion euros ($3.5 billion) to survive a serious downturn, and that 16 other lenders passed but should raise more money.

    Of the failing banks -- those whose so-called core capital fell below 5% -- five are from Spain, two from Greece* and one from Austria, according to results released by euro area banking watchdogs. Of those that passed but could stand to bulk up, with core capital of 5%-6%, nearly MORE

    - Jul 15, 2011 12:06 PM ET
  • Italy: Europe's Fannie Mae moment?

    After a long simmer, Europe's debt crisis is coming to a boil.

    The market has turned against the Continent with a vengeance. European bank stocks sold off for the second straight day, while the euro sank against both the dollar (see chart, right) and the Swiss franc.

    The euro hit $1.41, down a nickel from its recent high just ahead of the July 4 holiday here. Big European financial companies, ranging from Deutsche MORE

    - Jul 11, 2011 11:47 AM ET
  • China's debt bomb

    As the world watches the Greek credit crisis unfold, a Sino-debt disaster is brewing halfway around the world.

    Jim Chanos, the hedge fund manager who is famously shorting China, told Fortune late last year that the country was "embarking on something unprecedented." He was referring to the massive construction boom that has been underway for years, and that was supercharged by a 2008 stimulus package that pumped four trillion yuan ($586 MORE

    - Jun 28, 2011 10:41 AM ET
  • U.S. overspending: the Portugal parallel

    The Greeks were liars and the Irish couldn't say no to their bankers. So how will we explain it away when Portugal hits the wall?

    Just two months after Ireland's bailout, investors are rattling the next weak link in the euro chain. Portuguese 10-year government bonds now yield a bruising 7%, more than double the rate in export powerhouse Germany.

    It gets worse. Portugal last week paid 3.7% for debt that matures in MORE

    - Jan 11, 2011 6:56 AM ET
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.