Elevation Partners

Will China's Fosun pay 'less than $250 million' for Forbes?

February 20, 2014: 2:27 PM ET

Forbes Media is reportedly close to a deal with Fosun International. Who exactly is Fosun, and how much will it have to pay?

By Dan Primack & Scott Cendrowski


FORTUNE -- Last fall came word that Forbes Media LLC was on the block for a reported $400 million, with Deutsche Bank (DB) hired to find a buyer. The price-tag was stunning. Not only was it a much larger multiple than where other business media properties were valued, but even Forbes shareholder Elevation Partners was holding it at a much lower cost.

Rumored suitors included German publisher Axel Springer and Singapore-based conglomerate Spice Global.

Then yesterday came a report that Forbes was nearing a deal to sell itself for "less than $250 million" to China's Fosun International.

So two questions: What is Fosun International, and is Forbes really going to be sold for less than $250 million?

Fosun: Bringing 'Buffett Model' top China

Fosun is publicly-traded in Hong Kong, and controlled by billionaire chairman Guo Guangchang. In China, it runs sprawling businesses in real estate, insurance, pharmaceuticals, iron ore mining, steel-making and private equity. Over the first six months of 2013, the latest reporting period, the company posted revenue of $4 billion. More recently, it has been expanding its operations outside of China's borders.

Over the past few years, Fosun has bought a stake in the Greek fashion label Folli Follie, paid $725 million to J.P. Morgan (JPM) for One Chase Manhattan Plaza in New York, acquired Club Med, bought an Israeli medical equipment maker, invested in the U.S. luxury brand St. John Knits International and boosted insurance assets after launching ventures with Prudential Financial and Peak Reinsurance in China.

Guo says he has even bigger ambitions for Fosun. After winning the bid for Portugal's biggest insurance company earlier this year, he said in a statement, "This marks a solid step for Fosun to evolve into Warren Buffett's model." Perhaps that also means the Oracle's investments in print media. Buffett was an early and longtime holder of The Washington Post Co., which was recently sold to Amazon founder Jeff Bezos. Fosun already publishes Forbes' Chinese edition, which enjoys a strong brand in the county.

Fosun International dropped 2% in Hong Kong trading on Thursday following the Forbes buyout rumors, before eventually climbing back to end the day little changed. The company's senior director of investor relations didn't respond to e-mails and calls on Thursday.

"Less than $250 million"

When Forbes first went on the block last fall, multiple sources tell me that Time Warner (TWX) offered around $175 million but was completely rebuffed. Do not pass go, do not come into the second round of bidding. (note: Fortune is published by Time Warner subsidiary Time Inc.).

But if Forbes is ultimately going to sell for "less than $250 million," why wouldn't a $175 million bidder been asked to sweeten the pot? If, for no other reason, than to possibly put some pricing pressure on more generous suitors like Fosun? Just doesn't seem to make sense.

We can only come up with three possible explanations:

  1. 1. Initial bids were indeed much higher, but Forbes is having an absolutely disastrous Q1.
  2. 2. The devil is in details. TheStreet.com mentions that, under terms of the Fosun deal, the Forbes family would "to retain a stake in the business." So perhaps "less than $250 million" is what Fosun would pay, but the actual enterprise value is actually a bit higher.
  3. 3. TheStreet.com is wrong, and Forbes actually is going to sell for well more than $250 million (something that a source familiar with the situation was telling me last night). Remember, any price below $264 million means that the Forbes family doesn't get any liquidity, due to a prior preferred stock deal with Elevation Partners.

All we know for sure is that while Fosun makes sense as the buyer, the new price talk doesn't comport with what Forbes and its bankers did last fall.

Sign up for Dan's daily email newsletter on deals and deal-makers: GetTermSheet.com

  • In Forbes sale, Bono would get paid first

    The Forbes media empire is on the block, but most of the proceeds would go to a minority shareholder.

    FORTUNE -- Financial media giant Forbes is on the block for a reported $400 million, with Deutsche Bank (DB) beating the bushes for a buyer. If there is a sale, however, relatively few of the proceeds would go into the Forbes family's pockets.

    Back in 2006, a private equity firm called Elevation MORE

    - Nov 16, 2013 3:57 PM ET
  • Breaking down the $135 million Sonos deal

    Going beyond the noise.

    FORTUNE -- Sonos, a maker of wireless home audio systems, has raised $135 million in a growth equity round led by Kohlberg Kravis Roberts (KKR). Elevation Partners and Redpoint Ventures also participated, while existing company shareholders include Index Ventures and BV Capital.

    Three notes:

    1. According to All Things D, only about $45 million of the round is primary capital. The remainder is founder/early shareholder liquidity. Unclear if BV is MORE

    - Jun 19, 2012 11:07 AM ET
  • No, Facebook did not make Bono world's richest musician

    Reports of Bono's payday have been greatly exaggerated.

    FORTUNE -- There have been a lot of silly things written about Facebook (FB) in the past 24 hours, but this item over at HuffingtonPost takes the cake:

    Of course, HuffPo was not alone. Similar sophistry was posted at MSN, music blog NME and, most egregiously, on NASDAQ's own website.

    Here's the reality: Bono is a partner with Elevation Partners, a private equity firm that invested MORE

    - May 18, 2012 5:39 PM ET
  • Reviewing Elevation's Yelp investment

    How Elevation Partners fared with Yelp.

    Online review site Yelp (YELP) went public earlier today, with shares rocketing more than 64% as of 2:20pm. The last time Yelp raised money was in January 2010, through a private investment from Elevation Partners. So, now that we have a third-party valuation, let's see how Elevation is making out.

    Before beginning, let me stress that Elevation did not sell any shares in the IPO and MORE

    - Mar 2, 2012 2:30 PM ET
  • The Forbes family's big deal causes big trouble

    After default, emergency restructuring was needed to satisfy lenders.

    FORTUNE -- The Forbes family has poked itself in the eye with its "capitalist tool."

    Like many publishers, Forbes Media has struggled during the financial crisis. But according to nonpublic documents made available to Fortune, the company has been under more financial strain than previously believed. Forbes Media violated covenants on a revolving credit line that it took out in 2006, according to MORE

    - Jul 28, 2011 5:00 AM ET
  • Roger McNamee inscribes Silver Lake in the 'Failure Chronicles'

    Success, it seems, is all in the eye of the beholder.

    For most of us, Silver Lake Partners would fit the bill. Since being founded in 1999, the tech-focused private equity firm has amassed $14 billion in assets under management, opened offices around the globe, produced strong returns for investors and diversified its investment strategy. For Silver Lake co-founder Roger McNamee, however, Silver Lake is about opportunity lost.

    McNamee was one of MORE

    - Mar 18, 2011 2:22 PM ET
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by WordPress.com VIP.