euro crisis

Why Greeks are overworked while Germans go home early

February 3, 2014: 12:05 PM ET

Workers in struggling Southern European countries put in far more hours per year than their northern counterparts.

By Ian Mount

A wood yard worker in Athens, Greece

A wood yard worker in Athens, Greece

FORTUNE -- Take a wild guess: Which country's workers put in more hours on the job, Germany or Greece?

A Madrid think tank called the Institute of Economic Studies (IEE, in Spanish) recently released the kind of provocative study meant to incite debate. Based on data from the OECD, it noted that workers in struggling Southern European countries like Greece, Spain, Italy, and Portugal put in far more hours per year than their Protestant work-ethic-infused counterparts in Northern countries like Germany and the Netherlands. Southern Europeans may have been suffering through an economic crisis, the IEE seemed to be saying, but they weren't lazy.

"We work more hours, for example, than in Germany, the U.K., and the other so-called northern countries. But working more hours doesn't mean that things come out better for us," said Almudena Semur, IEE's manager.

Greek workers put in 2,034 hours per year, and those in Spain, Italy, and Portugal worked around the OECD average of 1,765. In the North, however, German workers only managed to put in 1,397 hours, the Dutch 1,381, and Norwegians 1,420.

MORE: Finally, a retirement plan friendly to smaller savers?

The numbers offer a picture of the dual realities of European labor, and the markedly different responses to the financial crisis by employers in Southern and Northern Europe.

"If we talk of before the crisis, we see that the level of employment in Spain and Germany was more or less equal," said Alfredo Pastor, a professor of economics at Barcelona's IESE Business School. "In the crisis, what was most adjusted in Germany was hours worked, while in Spain it was the number of employees."

In a paper from the Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA, in German) in Bonn, "Short-Time Work: The German Answer to the Great Recession," the authors noted that while Germany's GDP fell by 4.7% in 2009, the size of its working population remained at a record high because short-time work regulations, which offered wage supplements for those who suffered temporary work-hour reductions, helped companies avoid layoffs. Without the wide use of "short-time" work (Kurzarbeit, in German) unemployment in Germany would have risen by about twice as much as it did, the authors said.

"What the Germans tend to do is reduce hours worked and wait for a good day. And the good days have come back quite quickly. In Spain, that's another story," says Pascal Marianna, a labor economist at the OECD in Paris.

Many Northern European countries have also been making a long-standing push to increase the level of part-time work to help worker and business flexibility and to increase the participation of women in the workforce. In 2012, the percentage of workers working part-time was 22% in Germany, 38% in the Netherlands, and only 14% in Spain, according to OECD data.

"In Germany, during the last decade we have seen a major increase in part-time work, especially among women," says the OECD's Marianna. According to Marianna, the employment rate of women in Germany increased from 58% to 68% between 2000 and 2012.

And then, of course, there is the issue of productivity. According to OECD statistics, the GDP per hour worked in Germany, the Netherlands, and Norway were $58, $60, and $87, respectively, while in Greece, Portugal, Italy, and Spain, the numbers ranged from $34 to $50.

For IESE economics professor Pastor, the solution is obvious: Make Spain's rigid and long siesta-split workday more flexible, and push more part-time work.

MORE: Fear be damned: This is the time to invest in emerging markets

"The work hours in Spain are very irrational. In Spain, we reward people who are at work many hours," he says. "Without a doubt, it's better to promote part-time work."

At the end of the day, the IEE put out its findings to show that while Spain was near the OECD average and handily beat Germany in terms of hours worked per worker, that in itself was little to celebrate.

"What we have to do, in order to make our businesses more competitive, is to work better," IEE manager Almudena Semur said. "Working more doesn't help if you don't work better."

  • 8 banks fail Europe's stress test

    European regulators said 8 banks will need 2.5 billion euros ($3.5 billion) to survive a serious downturn, and that 16 other lenders passed but should raise more money.

    Of the failing banks -- those whose so-called core capital fell below 5% -- five are from Spain, two from Greece* and one from Austria, according to results released by euro area banking watchdogs. Of those that passed but could stand to bulk up, with core capital of 5%-6%, nearly MORE

    - Jul 15, 2011 12:06 PM ET
  • Moody's downgrades Greece again

    The Greek comedy took another twist Wednesday.

    Moody's downgraded Greece again, putting 50-50 odds on a default thanks to the country's strapped finances and tortured European politics.

    The rating agency cut Greece's rating to Caa1, its third-lowest rating, and kept its outlook negative, meaning another downgrade could come soon. Moody's cited rising chances that the country won't stabilize its debt burden, which has been getting heavier as borrowings rise and the economy MORE

    - Jun 1, 2011 3:41 PM ET
  • U.S. banks shake off bond jitters

    A volatile month has bent bond buyers every which way, but there's no sign the market is about to break.

    November started with the Federal Reserve pledging to buy $600 billion in Treasury securities in a move that, against all odds, sent prices of the targeted bonds tumbling. That selloff, the first sizable one in six months, sent buyers scurrying away from the market for municipal bonds and high-yield corporate debt.

    Adding to the MORE

    - Nov 24, 2010 1:05 PM ET
  • European regulators defend stress tests

    Bank regulators pushed back at a press report that roiled financial markets Tuesday.

    The Committee of European Bank Supervisors, the group that conducted and publicized the stress tests on 91 big European banks in July,  issued a statement Wednesday defending its handling of data on banks' exposure to sovereign debt issued by stressed governments.

    CEBS said the tests sought to provide "a meaningful and consistent view of banks exposures to sovereign debt." MORE

    - Sep 8, 2010 11:26 AM ET
  • Update: Bank bailout fears batter Ireland

    The mounting cost of a giant bank bailout is pushing Ireland perilously close to sovereign debt crisis territory.

    The cost of insuring against a default on Irish government bonds jumped 4% Wednesday to a record, and the government's cost of borrowing in the bond markets for 10 years rose above 6%, as officials met to discuss what to do about the foundering Anglo Irish Bank.

    The government is expected to make a MORE

    - Sep 8, 2010 10:05 AM ET
  • Gold glitters on debt jitters

    Questions about the health of Europe's banks helped send the price of gold near record levels Tuesday.

    Gold rose $7 an ounce to $1,258, after a series of reports raised questions about banks' capital levels and their exposure to bonds issued by stressed nations such as Greece, Portugal, Ireland, Italy and Spain.

    Tuesday's rally takes the gold price up almost $100 an ounce from its midsummer low and just a few dollars from MORE

    - Sep 7, 2010 12:17 PM ET
  • Bank stocks banking on trouble

    So much for the banks' European vacation.

    Shares in the big global banks tumbled Friday. The deepest sell-offs were in Europe, where even the promise of a big bailout package hasn't quieted concerns over the future of the euro zone and bank exposure to stressed economies.

    But U.S. banks slumped too, as investors continue to fret over banks' exposure to problems in Europe and questions about how far the Senate will go MORE

    - May 14, 2010 12:19 PM ET
    Posted in: ,
  • The hypocrisy of the Germans

    Maybe Teutonic discipline isn't all it's cracked up to be.

    Fortune's Katie Benner notes today that the euro zone's crisis has given Germany a chance to throw its ample weight around. Default fears in Greece, and to a lesser degree Portugal, have sent investors rushing into both gold and its closest paper equivalent,  German government debt. In an echo of the flight to safety that has sent U.S. Treasury yields tumbling, MORE

    - May 12, 2010 11:01 AM ET
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.