By Mohamed A. El-Erian
FORTUNE -- Many are hoping that, after dominating the headlines for almost two weeks now, the tiny island of Cyprus will soon return to virtual obscurity in the global financial media. For this to happen, the latest country rescue package needs to hold. Yet prospects are highly uncertain -- confirming a gradual shift in power in Europe and fueling concerns for the wellbeing of other small European economies, as well as the broader economic and financial stability of the region.
As most readers know, officials from Europe and the IMF badly bungled the first attempt at rescuing Cyprus. Realizing the policy slippage, and after a rather unusual (and quite public) blame game, they scrambled and came up on Monday with a new package. While technically more plausible, it faces considerable implementation challenges.
The second rescue restored the usual safeguards enjoyed by insured bank deposits (i.e., those below EUR 100,000). It eschewed a rather blunt generalized approach to the banking system, opting instead for a more sensible entity-specific one. And it incorporated more common sense in allocating burden sharing on the capital structure, including imposing severe losses on bond holders and other senior creditors.
In light of the severity of the Cypriot situation, and given official creditors' hesitation to commit their taxpayers to another large financing, the new rescue involved another notable, and highly unusual feature -- that of very significant haircuts on uninsured bank deposits. Partial initial indications suggest that these could be as high as 80% for the most problematic bank, and 40% for another.
It is not unheard of for officials to need two rounds to rescue a country. Indeed, it was the case for several cases in the past, including Mexico in 1995 and Korea in 1999. What is unusual is that, this time around, the second round came so quickly after the first. The reasons for this speak to more than inadequate design, generalized bailout fatigue, and mounting coordination problems. They also highlight four areas of major uncertainties that warrant close monitoring.
The first test for the Cypriot rescue will come as soon as the government reopens the country's banks (currently scheduled for tomorrow). It is critical that this process be orderly, transparent and sustained. Put bluntly, the already shaky rescue package will not survive persistent images of bank runs and widening street protests.
This speaks to the second uncertainty: whether the government is able to maintain a set of capital controls that dissuades people from pulling their money out of the country while at the same time, and this is critical, not totally choking an already-struggling economy via widespread shortages, hoarding, and black markets.
Well-functioning capital controls are difficult to design and implement. Importantly, the Cypriot government needs to convey that these controls are both temporary and reversible. And this is very hard to do when, being part of the single currency eurozone, it cannot depreciate its currency as a means of realigning price incentives and limiting the inevitable leakages that accompany capital controls.
Third, it is not clear how long it will take for some sense of normalcy to return to the functioning of the Cypriot economy. Today the country is paralyzed by much more than the immediate shock of the crisis. Under pressure from its European partners, it is in the process of permanently dismantling its status as an offshore banking center. Absent a new growth model and much greater external financial support -- both of which are unlikely to materialize quickly -- the economy risks falling into a protracted depression.
Finally, there are questions on how depositors will now behave in other vulnerable European countries, especially those with large uninsured accounts. Will they feel compelled to take cash out of banks now that Europe has broken all sorts of taboos?
Most analysts are rightly inclined to focus on the larger economies such as Italy and Spain. In doing so, they should also keep a keen eye on what would normally be regarded as the smaller "non-systemic" ones (particularly Slovenia and those with a large banking system relative to their national economies). History warns us that heightened instability in a handful of "non-systemics" can easily become systemic.
These four economic and financial uncertainties have notable socio-political dimensions. The longer they persist, the higher the risk that citizens would continue to lose trust in the traditional political order and established political parties -- thus reducing the scope for the effective implementation of reform programs and also increasing the risk of social disorder.
Cyprus is more than the sad story of a small European economy which allowed its banks to grow excessively and irresponsibly. It is also an indicator of an important gradual shift in the major determinants of European stability -- away from the guiding hands of national governments, the European Commission, the European Central Bank, and the International Monetary Fund and to the less coordinated actions of increasingly frustrated and disillusioned citizens in a growing number of countries.
What is happening in Cyprus today is reminding citizens in other countries of an old saying: Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me.
To predict how Europe evolves from here, analysts need to broaden their focus well beyond the traditional national and multilateral power centers. Increasingly, the fate of a growing number of European economies rests in the hands of citizens who feel they have no choice but to self-insure financially, disconnect economically, and protest socially.
Mohamed A. El-Erian is the CEO and co-chief investment officer of PIMCO. He also chairs the U.S. president's global development council.
Despite an eleventh-hour deal, the fallout from the Cypriot crisis is far from over.
By Cyrus Sanati
FORTUNE -- The banking crisis in Cyprus is far from resolved and will almost certainly morph into a far more serious sovereign debt crisis in the near future, threatening investors around the globe. The revised bailout agreement hatched over the weekend will still leave the island nation's banking-centric economy in ruin, thus limiting the government's ability MOREMar 26, 2013 9:27 AM ET
The Cyprus bailout illustrates why short-term tactical compromises are no substitute for proper, albeit much more difficult, strategic decision-making.
By Mohamed El-Erian
FORTUNE -- The botched bailout of Cyprus sheds light on more than just the difficulties Europeans face in collectively designing a complicated country rescue package. It also serves as a reminder of the mismatch between Europe's multiple objectives and its more limited tools. And it illustrates why short-term tactical MOREMar 19, 2013 9:56 AM ET
Wall Street is heavily invested in bank debt across the European Union. If banks begin falling as a result of the Cyprus 'bailout,' investors in the U.S. will feel the loss.
By Cyrus Sanati
FORTUNE -- The terms of the Cypriot "bailout" announced late Friday are simply atrocious and should be revised to protect small depositors to avoid potentially crippling bank runs from popping up across Europe. Forcing bank losses on MOREMar 18, 2013 11:07 AM ET
Proposed limits on banker bonuses would cause the slow death of what continues to be - despite overregulation and higher taxes - a very profitable industry for Europe.
By Cyrus Sanati
FORTUNE -- The European Union and Switzerland would be wise to rethink recently proposed policies restricting bonus payouts. The new rules, which cap bonuses for banking employees in the EU and for all employees of publicly-traded companies in Switzerland, could MOREMar 5, 2013 11:31 AM ET
Don't be fooled by the market's non-reaction to the downgrade of the United Kingdom's debt. The government must give the perception that the country is a safe haven for foreign investors.
By Cyrus Sanati
FORTUNE -- The loss of the U.K.'s coveted AAA credit rating shouldn't be taken lightly. While some might try to downplay the significance of the loss, the bruise to the nation's credibility could have painful economic consequences MOREFeb 26, 2013 5:00 AM ET
All eyes this weekend will be on one large economy in Europe, Italy, and one small one, Cyprus. Elections there could send the markets back into a frenzied state of uncertainty over the euro's future.
By Cyrus Sanati
FORTUNE -- The outcome of two elections this coming weekend could push Europe back to the edge of economic calamity. Sovereign bond investors in London and on the continent will be watching voter MOREFeb 22, 2013 5:00 AM ET
From the outset, Britain viewed membership in the European Union as a means to access wealthy consumers, and not much else. Now that the payoff is lower, the UK is getting cold feet.
By Mohamed El-Erian
FORTUNE -- In one big lunge, UK Prime Minister Cameron's promise of an in/out referendum on membership of the European Union has made explicit a number of simmering issues that are both complex and consequential -- MOREJan 29, 2013 9:32 AM ET
Don't believe the politicians. The common currency can't survive as is. Here's the right way to handle a split.
FORTUNE – Roger Bootle prides himself on being something of a modern-day Nostradamus -- with good reason. In 1999 the British economist predicted a bursting of the dotcom bubble, and in his 2003 book, Money for Nothing, he forecast a worldwide crash in housing that would prove dire for the financial system. MOREShawn Tully, senior editor-at-large - Sep 25, 2012 5:00 AM ET
From up close, it looks like the 'poorer' nations could do just fine without a single currency.
By Erin Burnett, contributor
FORTUNE -- This summer trips to Europe opened my eyes to something: There's a lack of passion in Europe for keeping the euro. Yes, the pain of a breakup would be severe. But many of the poorer southerners of Europe don't seem to feel that they need "Europe" anymore.
That, at MORESep 12, 2012 5:00 AM ET
|Bernanke's advice for college grads|
|The Winklevoss twins are Bitcoin bulls|
|Bloomberg's lazy Apple bias|
|Signs of new housing bubble in several areas|
|Stocks finish higher for fourth straight week|