By Lynnley Browning
FORTUNE -- Hedge fund executives who descended on Miami last month for a conference on unpaid property taxes were treated to waterfront cruises of estates owned by Madonna, Shaquille O'Neal, and Elizabeth Taylor. But unlike those celebrity residences, the houses the profit-chasing investors were hunting at the gathering have a prosaic facade: tax liens.
Far from the mansions of Greenwich, Conn., houses owned by homeowners struggling with delinquent property-tax bills are sparking a gold rush by the elite money pools. Leading the recent lien-buying surge is Fortress Investment Group, the $53 billion alternative investments company now working with former executives who drove J.P. Morgan's prior rush into the business from 2008 through mid-2011.
David Zussman, a Newport Beach, Calif.-based investor in foreclosed homes, calls the buying frenzy by hedge funds "reminiscent of junk bonds."
The investing has only accelerated amid a federal antitrust probe of past bid-rigging at some auctions and a pullback last year by large banks from the market. Still, some hedge funds are finding help from Wall Street, as big banks that sold risky mortgages in recent years, including Wells Fargo (WFC) and Capital One (COF), extend low-interest credit to buy liens.
Here's how it works: Several times each year, municipalities in 28 states, plus Washington, D.C., Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands, auction off scores of property tax liens, also called certificates, to investors. The rules and rates vary, but homeowners typically have from six months to two years to pay back the notes, plus interest, or lose their homes to the investors. Less than 1% of sales go that foreclosure route, said Brad Westover, executive director of the National Tax Lien Association, which sponsored the Miami conference. Investors immediately pay the municipalities the taxes owed, then over time collect that amount plus interest from the homeowner.
With buyers identified only by numbers or unrelated names, the fragmented, unregulated industry is opaque. Even the market's size is debated -- $15 billion a year, according to Howard Liggett, the chief executive of Distressed Real Estate Consulting Services, or $5 billion a year, according to the National Tax Lien Association, a trade group. While returns are a closely kept secret, investors typically make between 2.5% and 10% a year, or in the low teens for larger buys.
"The hedge funds are chasing yield in this business" says Albert Friedman, a principal at Alterna Capital, an alternative investment firm in Boca Raton that buys tax liens.
Insiders estimate hedge funds now control 40% of the tax-lien market, from under 5% five years ago, with regional banks, obscure partnerships sporting names like God's ATM LLC, and mom-and-pop investors making up the rest.
Interviews and auction records point to recent buying by Apollo Global Management, MD Sass, Denver-based Arrowpoint Asset Management, Tang Capital of San Diego and Cazenovia Creek Asset Management in Charlotte, N.C., as big buyers. BlackRock (BLK) expects net revenues of $242 million from its tax-lien investments over five years through 2016, according to a securities filing. The firms declined to comment, citing the ongoing probe, or did not respond to calls.
But Fortress (FIG) is what Thomas McOsker, a co-founder of BloxTrade, an online secondary market for liens, calls "the 300-pound gorilla in the market." While the company jumped into the business around four years ago, it has ramped up its buying in over the past two years in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Florida, and elsewhere, pouring at least hundreds of millions of dollars into the business.
"We like the investment from a risk-return standpoint," said Michael Fallacara, a Fortress managing director, "but the investment process can be tangled and laborious."
Recent auction records show Fortress working through Tower Capital Management, a "tax lien monetization" firm in Morristown, N.J. that operates behind-the-scenes to place bids at lien auctions in Florida, New York, Arizona, Tennessee, California, and elsewhere on Fortress's behalf. Fortress bids via special entities with names like Tudor Tax Lien, Anc Acquisition General, and Tower DBW, records show.
Tower Capital's chief executive, John Garzone, ran Xpand, the J.P. Morgan tax-lien unit that received grand-jury subpoenas in 2010 as part of the federal bid-rigging probe. By the time J.P. Morgan (JPM) said it had exited the lien business in 2011, Garzone and other former Xpand executives, including Neil Harreveld, had joined Tower and stepped into the breach. Reached for comment, an unidentified Tower employee said, "We're not interested in talking," and hung up the telephone.
Proponents argue that the sales put money into the hands of cash-strapped cities to fund schools and roads. But to counter bad optics, the recent Miami conference, held at the Eden Roc Renaissance Resort and Spa, raised $10,040 from a record-setting 206 attendees for the National Coalition for the Homeless.
Said one investor who declined to be identified: "We don't want other hedge funds to know" about this industry.
How did New York and New Jersey jump to the top of the foreclosure list, behind only Florida? Red tape.
FORTUNE – Just as most of us believe we've seen the worst of the housing market's collapse, two unlikely states are only now getting hit with a wave of foreclosures: New York and New Jersey.
The region was largely spared when home prices disastrously tumbled in 2007. New York and New Jersey, MORENin-Hai Tseng, Writer - Apr 15, 2013 6:00 AM ET
As Fortune predicted last year, a robust recovery in home prices is under way.
FORTUNE -- In spring 2011 this writer penned a controversial cover story titled "The Return of Real Estate" that predicted a strong rebound in housing. At the time, prices and sales were still tumbling, and the prevailing view among economists and pundits was that the slide would drag on and on. But Fortune's contrarian forecast proved right. MOREShawn Tully, senior editor-at-large - Oct 18, 2012 5:00 AM ET
Monitor says he has gotten over 1,000 complaints.
FORTUNE --The borrower bailout remains on hold.
In the last few months, there has been more and more indications that banks, investors and regulators would finally embrace loan modifications that reduce how much borrowers owe. It hasn't happened yet. Edward DeMarco, who is the head of the government agency that oversees Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, says he is still against so-called principal reductions.
And MOREStephen Gandel, senior editor - Aug 2, 2012 6:00 AM ET
The banks spend a lot of time carping about economic uncertainty. But they have no one but themselves to blame for the latest pratfall at Ally Financial.
Ally, the car lender formerly known as GMAC that was rescued after a disastrous spin down subprime lending lane, had been hoping to do an initial public offering this month but is now more likely looking at the fall, the Financial Times reported.
The firm has MOREColin Barr - Jun 10, 2011 11:49 AM ET
Many judges presiding over the countless foreclosure cases around the country are taking steps to stop fraud, but in a few key courts, the bench takes the opposite track.
By Abigail Field, contributor
FORTUNE -- Since last fall, the judicial system has been confronting foreclosure fraud across the country. As the scale of the problem became publicized, it's been increasingly hard for judges not to notice that the banks have consistently filed MOREApr 18, 2011 1:21 PM ET
Think Washington is going soft on the banks again? You have company – at the FDIC, no less.
The three primary federal bank regulators – the Federal Reserve, the Office of Thrift Supervision and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency – issued enforcement actions Wednesday that order the biggest U.S. banks to clean up their foreclosure mills.
The move, affecting 14 institutions and promising fines at some undetermined point down MOREColin Barr - Apr 13, 2011 3:48 PM ET
Regulators charged the biggest U.S. banks with "unsafe and unsound practices" on foreclosures, and ordered a sweeping overhaul of their mortgage operations.
The move is the strongest federal response so far to the bankers' massive, greed-driven misconduct during the crisis of the past half-decade. It comes after a months-long federal review of the banks' handling of mortgage paperwork and foreclosure actions.
But in a telling omission, the regulators didn't say how big the fines they will assess might be MOREColin Barr - Apr 13, 2011 2:01 PM ET
Forget stocks. Don't bet on gold. After four years of plunging home prices, the most attractive asset class in America is housing.
From his wide-rimmed cowboy hat to his roper boots, Mike Castleman fits moviedom's image of the lanky Texas rancher. On a recent March evening, Castleman is feeding cattle biscuits to his two pet longhorn steers, Big Buddy and Little Buddy, on his 460-acre Bar Ten Creek Ranch in Dripping MOREShawn Tully, senior editor-at-large - Mar 28, 2011 5:00 AM ET
The big banks face fresh scrutiny of their handling of the mortgage mess – from their own boards, no less.
Shareholders at Bank of America (BAC), Citigroup (C) and Wells Fargo (WFC) could vote this spring to compel their audit committees to investigate the banks' mortgage and foreclosure practices, and report back by fall.
The votes will come despite much eye-rolling from the banks, which have tended to be less than forthcoming on MOREColin Barr - Mar 24, 2011 6:33 AM ET
|Feds seize 14 7-Eleven stores in ID theft case|
|Kickstarter pulls plug on scam minutes before $120,000 heist|
|10,000 Apple accounts subject to data requests|
|NASA selects more women astronauts|
|Google stock split closer to reality|