Moving Michelangelo: Trading places at the Kimbell Museum

January 31, 2014: 12:02 PM ET

For 39 years, an obscure federal program run by the National Endowment for the Arts has insured -- free of charge -- billions worth of museum artwork. There's just one very odd catch …

By Peter Elkind

The Piano Pavilion at the Kimbell museum in Fort Worth, Texas

The Piano Pavilion at the Kimbell museum in Fort Worth, Texas

FORTUNE -- As Uncle Sam sees it, even a $135-million museum building designed by one of the world's greatest architects is in need of a shakedown cruise.

For 39 years, an obscure federal program run by the National Endowment for the Arts has insured -- free of charge -- billions worth of precious artwork shown in traveling exhibitions around the country. By assuming this risk, the program has saved the hosting museums an estimated $375 million in insurance costs, helping make such shows possible.

But there's one major caveat to the program: The feds won't insure the first exhibit in a new or renovated building, no matter its architectural pedigree.

So it was in Fort Worth, Texas, when the long-awaited addition to the Kimbell Art Museum opened late last year. The generously endowed Kimbell owns an exquisite collection of masterworks and occupies a revered building designed by the late Louis Kahn, featuring barrel-vaulted art galleries. Since its opening in 1972, the Kimbell has often been described as America's finest small museum.

MORE: Forever stamps: An investment that can't be licked

The problem is that it was too small. The arrival of visiting exhibits regularly required the Kimbell staff to stash much of its own collection in storage, out of view for weeks at a time.

After two decades of debate -- driven by fears of desecrating Kahn's jewel -- a resolution to this problem was finally reached when the museum commissioned a separate 101,300-square-foot structure, located across a lawn from the Kahn building and designed by Renzo Piano, the famed Italian architect behind more than 20 high-profile museum projects. The Piano Pavilion's galleries were specifically built to provide space for traveling exhibits, allowing the Kimbell's permanent collection to remain in its original home.

But when the Piano building opened in November, it featured much of the Kimbell's relocated permanent collection, while a recently arrived visiting exhibit from the Art of Institute of Chicago, "The Age of Matisse and Picasso," occupied its usual space in the Kahn building.

This arrangement -- call it the Multi-Million-Dollar Artwork Shuffle -- resulted from a quirk of the NEA's indemnity program, which won't (as program guidelines state) insure "inaugural exhibitions in new buildings or substantially renovated spaces."

To deal with this prohibition -- while still taking advantage of the government insurance program -- Kimbell director Eric M. Lee hung the Chicago art (including 10 Matisses and 10 Picassos) in the Kahn building, while moving his own precious works (including a Michelangelo, a Rembrandt, a Goya, and a Caravaggio) over to the new Piano structure.

The savings was considerable. "Insurance is a huge figure," notes Lee, who declined to specify the amount.

Temporarily relocating 71 paintings from the Kimbell's permanent works took about two weeks, as staff moved the paintings slowly on carts through a quarter-mile, climate-controlled tunnel connecting the two structures. When the Chicago exhibit departs in mid-February, the permanent collection will return to the Kahn building, presumably for good. Future visiting exhibits will then appear in the Piano Pavilion, as originally planned -- with the benefit of government insurance.

Patricia Loiko, NEA's indemnity program administrator, says the new-building restriction is imposed "in an abundance of caution." She offers a list of the potential hazards that delicate artworks face in a new structure: climate-control issues, security, protection from excess light sources, fire-suppression systems, and "off-gassing" of chemicals from new carpet or wood finishes.

"We need to make sure the material is flushed out and doesn't cause any damage to the artwork," says Loiko. "We just want to make sure there's no undue risk to the artwork or to the U.S. Treasury."

While such risks at a museum like the Kimbell may seem small, the financial stakes are huge. With relatively modest deductibles capped at $500,000 for even a total loss, the government insures approved individual international exhibits up to a value of $1.2 billion; exhibits from U.S. museums are insured for up to $750 million.

Unlike, say, State Farm, the NEA program has no capital of its own to pay out claims. While any loss is backed by the "full faith and credit of the United States," according to program documents, if any indemnified objects are damaged or lost, the NEA must seek a special appropriation from Congress to make the art-lender whole.

Getting Congress to agree on writing a check for anything might seem a shaky proposition these days. Fortunately, that hasn't really been tested. In the 39-year history of the program, only two claims have ever been paid -- and neither can be blamed for ballooning the federal budget deficit.

The first occurred in 1982, when two paintings by Reuven Rubin, a Romanian-born painter, were reported stolen while being shipped back to Israel from an exhibit at the Jewish Museum in New York City. After a two-year investigation failed to locate the art, the government paid the owners $100,000 to settle the loss. The paintings were later recovered, and the entire $100,000 (after much legal wrangling) was eventually repaid to the U.S. Treasury.

MORE: Will aluminum lighten Ford's load?

The second claim resulted from $29,700 in damage in 1988 to two sculptures by Jean Arp, a European artist, while they were on loan to the Minneapolis Institute of Arts. After the deductible, the bill to the U.S. Treasury was a mere $4,700.

All in all, it's a track record any insurance company CEO would die for.

More than 1,200 exhibits, displaying 120,000 pieces of art, have been insured under the NEA program, says Loiko. "It's a remarkable loss ratio."

While Kimbell director Lee believes that "there are lots of issues that a building has that could potentially damage works of art," he feels confident that his new building, in reality, poses little risk. "Renzo Piano has built so many museums, you pretty much know you're not going to have any problems," notes Lee.

Having said that, he's not about to complain about the unusual provision in the NEA program and says relocating his permanent collection temporarily to qualify the visiting exhibit for government insurance was a no-brainer.

"It makes very expensive exhibitions more affordable," he notes. "It saved us a lot of money."

  • Can U.S. insurers stop gun violence?

    Liability insurance might be touted as a magic bullet to reduce gun deaths, but it's unlikely to make a big difference.

    FORTUNE -- U.S. insurers have helped discourage smoking and have even made driving safer, but can the industry also make America a less violent place?

    It's a tall order that would ask insurers to change the way they do business, but a handful of state lawmakers think so. Since December's tragic MORE

    - Feb 21, 2013 10:59 AM ET
  • AIG's Asian savior and rival

    AIG's former subsidiary, AIA, helped save the company. Now it could be a competitor.

    By Neel Chowdhury, contributor

    FORTUNE -- Insurance giant AIG has always enjoyed a special relationship with AIA, its former Asian subsidiary. After all, AIG was founded in Shanghai in 1919 by C.V. Starr, an adventurous Californian who pioneered life insurance in Asia. AIG (AIG) left China in 1950, one year after Mao's communist takeover, but AIA remained MORE

    Jan 9, 2013 5:00 AM ET
  • Don't let illness derail your retirement

    Even the best plan can be drained dry by getting sick. Here's how to protect yourself with disability insurance.

    By Janice Revell, contributor

    FORTUNE – Let's say you're a diligent retirement planner, the type who maxes out his 401(k) and IRA. Odds are, however, that you devote little thought to protecting the value of your human capital -- that is, your ability to earn and save money. Ignore it at MORE

    Jun 26, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • Record year for natural disaster losses

    Call this the year of catastrophes – and not just the financial kind that the guys in Washington and Brussels seem resolved to lead us into.

    Halfway through, this year is already the costliest on record for natural catastrophes, insurer Munich Re said Tuesday in its first-half review. Losses hit $265 billion in the first six months of 2011 – which exceeds the $220 billion in losses in the biggest previous MORE

    - Jul 12, 2011 11:23 AM ET
  • Market overreacts to Aflac nuke fears

    Investors roasting Aflac may be about to get plucked themselves.

    Shares in Aflac (AFL), the life and health insurer that does three-quarters of its business in Japan, tumbled 7% Tuesday. The Columbus, Ga., company has lost more than $3 billion of market value since Japan was hit Friday by a 9.0-magnitude earthquake and tsunami.

    The latest slide in Aflac shares comes amid fears that nuclear reactors hit by the tsunami will melt MORE

    - Mar 15, 2011 2:44 PM ET
  • Little shock, no awe in BofA email dump

    So much for Black Monday.

    Bank of America (BAC) shares dropped less than 1% Monday after a heavily hyped document dump turned up few documents and a lot of chin music.

    The emails released Monday morning at supposedly show employees at an insurance unit of BofA's Countrywide tried to hide foreclosure data from the government, by stripping some documents of identifying numbers. Bank of America told Reuters the documents were stolen MORE

    - Mar 14, 2011 10:44 AM ET
    Posted in: , , ,
  • The big ugly business of death

    If you are alive, you will not have your life insurance to spend; if you have it to spend, you aren't alive. This is a dilemma that only an investment banker can solve.

    By Moshe Silver, Hedgeye

    The baby boomers represent a great marketing opportunity – and hence a tremendous investment opportunity. One could have become very rich over the past six decades – and very predictably so – by investing successively MORE

    Feb 14, 2011 12:17 PM ET
  • FDIC looks to boost insurance fund

    Regulators plan to spend the next 17 years fattening up the federal deposit insurance fund.

    The Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. proposed rules Tuesday that eventually will nearly double the normal size of the taxpayer-backed fund that stands behind insured bank deposits, while gradually reducing the rates banks pay for insurance coverage.

    As part of the plan, the FDIC rescinded a rate increase it had planned for Jan. 1, in the MORE

    - Oct 19, 2010 3:19 PM ET
    Posted in: , , ,
  • Japan: the next global time bomb?

    A rapidly aging population and the government's deepening financial struggles make Japan a potential powder keg for international investments.

    By Darius Dale, analyst, Hedgeye

    We try to avoid hyperbole as much as possible at Hedgeye, the research firm where I work as an analyst. But after researching Japanese demographics and pension obligations, we have to say that in our opinion, they present one of the most dangerous potential risks to global investing MORE

    Sep 27, 2010 3:00 AM ET
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.