John Paulson
Rob Arnott: Most hedge funds disappoint
April 19, 2013: 11:51 AM ETFunds have underperformed at a time when they are drawing more and more money from middle class retirement accounts.
Rob Arnott
FORTUNE -- Hedge funds have been a bust.
That's how Robert Arnott, one of the nation's most successful investment managers, sees it. That's also the conclusion of a piece of research posted on his firm's website this week.
The research, which is titled "The Lure of Hedge Funds," directly refutes one of the key claims hedge funds managers make when they try to attract investors.
"There are some outstanding hedge funds, but they are considerably outnumbered by the multitudes of lousy ones," says Arnott, who heads Research Affiliates.
MORE: Hedge fund billionaires should avoid Puerto Rico
Hedge funds have traditionally been investment vehicles for the rich and universities. But in the past decade or so, they have drawn more and more money from public pensions and other accounts that hold the retirement funds of the middle class. Assets in hedge funds have more than tripled in the past decade to $2.25 trillion, according to Research Affiliates.
"The results have been a disappointment, and yet asset flows continue at an astronomical rate," says Arnott.
Part of that has to do with the sales pitch.
On the face of it, hedge funds have had a rough go of it recently. The vast majority of funds have done worse than the market for the past four years. To add insult to injury, last year even mutual funds outperformed hedge funds, which charge much higher fees than their rivals.
But hedge fund managers and the industry in general have long contended that those criticizing the funds for not having the highest returns are missing the point. They say hedge funds achieve their investment returns with less risk. You hear of the benefits of diversification, and risk-adjusted-returns. The pro-hedge fund camp argues that when you factor in the lower risk, investing in hedge funds is a better bet than just blindly putting your money in the market.
EARLIER: Rob Arnott's magic indexing formula
But Arnott says that's a bunch of baloney.
Blue bar shows what happened to the portfolios risk-adjusted returns when hedge fund were added. Source: Research Affiliates
To prove it, Arnott's colleagues started with a portfolio with a basic mix -- 60% stocks and 40% bonds. They then took a look at what would happen if the portfolio was shifted gradually, 10% at a time, into hedge funds. The result: Returns went down, and risk went up as the exposure to hedge funds increased, which is the opposite of what you want.
"Portfolio efficiency didn't improve," says RA's John West, author of the firm's hedge fund study. "In fact, it deteriorates with each additional allocation to hedge funds."
Hedge funds did a little better over the past 15 years. But even over that period, West found that a pension fund would have done better by adding a passively managed mix of commodities, real estate, and other assets, rather than expensive hedge funds.
Arnott's critique of hedge funds comes amid a number of recent high-profile blowups, which have thrown some cold water on the notion that hedge fund managers are masters of some kind of dark magic. John Paulson, who made billions for himself and his hedge fund clients, has reportedly lost $1 billion betting on gold. Bill Ackman, another hedge fund star, has stumbled with his bet to revive department store J.C. Penney (JCP).
MORE: El-Erian on the IMF: It's bipolar
And hedge funds and the pension world are starting to clash. On Thursday, the nation's second largest teachers union criticized a number of prominent fund managers for financing organizations that have called for the government to unfund public pensions. Said one union official, "They come to us with their hand out, and then they are stabbing us in the back."
-
Even housing bears bought big homes before the crash
A study by a Princeton University economics professor letting Wall Streeters off the hook for the financial crisis has a dubious premise.
FORTUNE -- If you believed poor mortgage lending and worthless securities were about to cause the biggest housing bust in American history, would you buy a house? I guess not.
That's the somewhat flimsy premise of a recent study by one Princeton economics professor and two others from the University MORE
Stephen Gandel, senior editor - Apr 1, 2013 1:22 PM ETPosted in: financial crisis, Hedge Funds, John Paulson, Magnetar, Noriel Roubini, real estate, Steve Eisman, Wall Street -
Billionaires should beware of Puerto Rico
The beaches are inviting, but Puerto Rico's political risks and its high crime rate should make wealthy tax-dodging Americans think twice before moving.
By Cyrus Sanati
FORTUNE -- John Paulson and other plutocrats should think twice before moving to Puerto Rico in search of a tax break. While the Caribbean Island's recent push to lure wealthy individuals from the U.S. mainland seems like a great deal, there is no guarantee that MORE
Mar 12, 2013 10:31 AM ET -
John Paulson misses on bank stocks, again
The hedge fund manager who called the crash continues to struggle in the recovery.
No one will ever call it his greatest trade ever. The worst? Maybe not.
John Paulson, the hedge fund manager who made billions betting against housing in 2007 and 2008, sold much of his stakes in the nation's largest financial firms in late-2011, missing this year's large rally in those stocks. Shares of Bank of America (BAC) and MORE
Stephen Gandel, senior editor - Feb 15, 2012 1:06 PM ET -
Fitch withdraws Sino-Forest rating
The ratings agency wants more information from Sino-Forest, and the embattled Chinese company refuses to comply.
FORTUNE -- The news just got a little worse Chinese forestry company Sino-Forest. Fitch announced Thursday that it will no longer rate Sino-Forest bonds because it isn't getting sufficient information from the company.
Fitch, one of world's three largest ratings agencies, asked Sino-Forest for "a more frequent and regular update of its offshore cash balances." The agency MORE
Katie Benner - Jul 14, 2011 11:41 AM ET -
John Paulson: Behind the backlash
We love to see our heroes fail, including the ones from Wall Street. But John Paulson's investors don't share the same concerns as the media.
FORTUNE -- Hedge fund manager John Paulson burst onto the public stage in a haze of awe and admiration after he bet that subprime mortgages would lose money and his prescience earned him a gargantuan $3.7 billion payday in 2007. In a rare feat for money MORE
Katie Benner - Jul 12, 2011 10:26 AM ET -
Hedge funds have run out of good ideas
Fund managers make ridiculous sums of money for the most obvious stock pick in history: Apple. Is this the best Wall Street has to offer?
Blame for the credit crisis has been doled out liberally. Depending on your particular persuasion, it was all the fault of Wall Street, greedy homeowners, lazy ratings agencies, Chinese currency manipulators, bad regulation, bad regulators, or shady mortgage types. The cohort that hasn't gotten its fair MORE
Duff McDonald, Contributing Editor - Feb 25, 2011 8:30 AM ET -
RAB Energy tops hedge funds in 2010
Hedge funds won't announce their final numbers for a few weeks yet, but investors already have some idea of the year's big winners and losers.
HSBC gives us a sneak peek with its latest weekly report on the hedge funds tracked by its alternative investment group – a broad array of investing styles and well-known fund managers.
According to the copy obtained by Fortune, 2010's top performing fund so far is MORE
Katie Benner - Jan 4, 2011 9:00 AM ET -
Another casino buy for John Paulson
The hedge fund manager is turning a distressed bond bet into a big stake in Harrah's.
John Paulson, the hedge fund manager who became a billionaire by betting on the subprime bust, took a 9.9% stake Friday in Harrah's, the casino operator that has been staggering under massive debts incurred two years ago in a private equity buyout.
Under the agreement, Harrah's will sell new debt at a 33% discount to Paulson (right) and the Las MORE
Colin Barr - Jun 4, 2010 10:05 AM ET
