Gold lawsuit sparks concerns of market manipulation, collusion

March 7, 2014: 1:38 PM ET

A recently filed lawsuit alleging price-fixing in the gold market is the latest evidence of increased scrutiny into the nearly century-old "London Gold Fix."


FORTUNE -- If you belong to an organization accused of gold market manipulation, it's probably not advantageous if your cohort goes by the nickname "the gold fix."

But that is the somewhat unfortunate moniker for the London Gold Market Fixing Ltd., a body of five banks -- Bank of Nova Scotia (BNS), Barclays (BCS), Deutsche Bank (DB), HSBC (HSBC), and Société Générale -- that meets twice daily to set the spot price for the world's most famous precious metal.

MORE: 4 reasons the gold market looks super shady right now

The group has come under scrutiny in recent months, with the latest blow being a federal lawsuit filed this week in New York, in which investor Kevin Maher is accusing the banks of manipulating the price of gold, causing him to lose money on his gold futures investments. The suit relies on the as-yet-unpublished work of Rosa Abrantes-Metz, the economist and whistleblower whose work helped uncover the LIBOR-manipulation scandal.

Abrantes-Metz's research reportedly identifies strange trading patterns around the times that the banks meet to determine gold prices. According to her research, "The structure of the benchmark is certainly conducive to collusion and manipulation, and the empirical data are consistent with price artificiality ... It is likely that co-operation between participants may be occurring."

The lawsuit follows reports that Germany's financial regulator, Bafin, has been investigating manipulation in the gold markets. According to BloombergElke Koenig, the president of the German regulator said in January that manipulation in the gold markets could be worse than the LIBOR-rigging scandal of 2012, which has cost banks roughly $6 billion in fines.

So what exactly is the gold fix, and why do we have it? Like a lot of institutions in global finance, this is one that justifies itself through tradition as much as necessity. The gold fix dates back to 1919, when the five leading gold dealers would meet in London every morning to settle on a price for physical gold sales. Over time, the gold fix added an afternoon meeting to accomodate traders in the U.S., and members eventually began to conduct the meeting via teleconference. The Maher complaint explains the mechanics:

  • First, the lead participant begins the fixing by proposing a price near the current spot price.
  • Second, firms declare how many bars of gold they want to buy/sell at the current market/spot price. This is based on current and contemporaneous client orders (those entered during the call) as well as proprietary need of each member.
  • Third, the price is then increased or decreased until the buy/sell amounts are within 50 bars, at which point that price becomes the spot price for gold.

The process is said to take anywhere between a few minutes to an hour. And though no wrongdoing has been proven, you can see how a setup with so few banks could be susceptible to collusion and price manipulation.

MORE: Janet Yellen: Fed will steer clear of bitcoin

So far, the only sign of an official response to these allegations has come from Germany, as it was reported in December that German regulators have seized documents from gold fix member Deutsche Bank, which subsequently hired a consultant to help it "undertake an assessment" of the bank's role in the gold fix. The bank is also reportedly looking to sell its seat on the gold fix, possibly to a state-owned Chinese bank.

Though no wrongdoing has yet been proven, it's increasingly looking like the gold fix process will have to be reformed in some way, even just to increase transparency and assure gold market participants of fair play. Gold enthusiasts, meanwhile, are using the scandal to justify the metal's rough 2013. Eric Sprott, CEO of the precious metal investment firm Sprott Asset Management, argued in a recent note to clients that demand for physical gold in 2013 was quite strong despite significant price declines in futures markets, concluding that it is "obvious" that at least some of the 2013 price declines were the result of "manipulation."

  • UBS' Libor charges: No longer a victimless crime

    The Justice Department's case against UBS shows borrowers were likely hurt.

    FORTUNE -- Early on in the Libor scandal, there was a sense that the systematic rigging of a key lending rate was a victimless crime. Wednesday's Justice Department charges against UBS should finally dispel that notion.

    It was assumed that if Libor rates had been pushed lower, as appeared to be the case, borrowers would have benefited. Even some municipal finance MORE

    - Dec 19, 2012 1:01 PM ET
    Posted in: , , ,
  • Baltimore: The city that sues the banks

    The Libor scandal plays out in an unlikely place - the streets of Charm City.

    FORTUNE -- It has been a year since Baltimore sued the big banks -- Bank of America (BAC), Barclays (BCS), Citibank (C), HSBC (HBC), J.P. Morgan (JPM), Lloyds (LYG), UBS (UBS), and WestLB -- the first of many lawsuits to claim that those institutions illegally manipulated the London interbank offer rate, or Libor. It was esoteric MORE

    - Aug 30, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • The death of Bob Diamond's dream for Barclays

    Caught up in the Libor scandal, the star investment banker and American CEO of the British bank was forced to resign. His departure represents the end of an era for big banks.

    FORTUNE -- By the time the call came, Bob Diamond knew his tenure as CEO of Barclays was at an end. It was 9:30 p.m. on Monday, July 2, and Diamond had just gotten home from the office when MORE

    - Jul 30, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • Barclays and Libor's (lack of) integrity committee

    Trade group put Barclays partially in charge of deciding whether Libor was broken.

    FORTUNE -- A husband and wife team who have launched a website critical of Wall Street practices have uncovered an ironic, and troubling, tidbit about Libor and Barclays.

    Just three months before Barclays admitted that numerous employees at the bank including top executives participated in manipulating Libor, and long after it was widely known to be under investigation, the MORE

    - Jul 25, 2012 2:30 PM ET
    Posted in: ,
  • Four fixes to the Libor scandal

    Now that we know what happened with the banks and Libor, what should we do to prevent it from happening again? Four options for reform or regulation, some better than others.

    FORTUNE – Investigations and talk of reform are dominating the headlines about the rate-fixing scandal tied to the London Interbank Offered Rate, or Libor. The interest rate influences many aspects of the world we live in, from Spanish and U.S. MORE

    - Jul 23, 2012 11:36 AM ET
    Posted in:
  • Barclays the biggest Libor liar? No, that may have been Citi

    A trio of studies indicates that Citigroup understated its borrowing costs more than others.

    Update 7/20, 10:00 A.M.

    FORTUNE -- Earlier this week, Citigroup CEO Vikram Pandit told analysts not to use Barclays' $450 million Libor settlement as a guidepost for what his firm might have to pay. And he could be right. Citigroup (C) might end up paying much more.

    A number of studies have shown that when it comes to lying MORE

    - Jul 19, 2012 12:18 PM ET
  • Wall Street's latest sucker: Your hometown

    Financial pressures have pushed cities and states to look for ways to save a buck, and into the arms of Wall Street hucksters.

    FORTUNE -- When it comes to Wall Street scandals these days you can pretty much bet who the biggest loser will be: Your hometown.

    The recent Libor fiasco is no different. The banks' alleged manipulation of the key benchmark interest rate may have cost municipalities, hospitals and other large MORE

    - Jul 11, 2012 3:48 PM ET
  • The Wall Street multibillion-dollar scandal no one is talking about

    The LIBOR trading scandal could turn out to be far worse for Wall Street than its mortgage troubles.

    FORTUNE -- Much of the talk about bad behavior on Wall Street since the financial crisis has been about mortgages with a little bit of insider trading sprinkled in. And that makes sense. Everyone immediately understands what a mortgage is. And the housing bust that resulted from all those bad home loans affected MORE

    - Mar 23, 2012 5:00 PM ET
  • Banks get scary again

    Everyone's afraid of the banks again -- including the bankers.

    Market-based anxiety measures have crept steadily higher over the past month, reflecting a marked shift in investor psychology. Less than two years after governments made promises totaling trillions of dollars to prop up the financial system, fears that Europe's banks will fall ill are pummeling the markets again.

    Libor, the rate at which highly rated banks borrow from one another on an MORE

    - May 25, 2010 10:10 AM ET
    Posted in: , ,
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.