Detroit proposes a lose-lose bankruptcy plan

February 21, 2014: 10:36 PM ET

Pensioners are outraged that they may only get two-thirds of the money owed them, but bondholders could take the bigger hit.

By Anne VanderMey


FORTUNE -- If the hallmark of a good deal is that neither side is happy, Detroit had a real winner on its hands Friday with the city's proposed bankruptcy restructuring.

First, pensioners were livid. Detroit proposed to pay its municipal retirees 66% of the money owed to them (or 74% if they sign onto the deal early). That drew outrage from the city's unions, which have been fighting for workers' pensions to be paid in full.

But those losses pale in comparison to the haircut that the bondholders would take -- a proposed 20 cents on the dollar for unsecured debt. That's better than the 10 cents on the dollar the city originally threatened, notes bankruptcy lawyer John Pottow, but it's still a huge hit. The Financial Guaranty Insurance Company has argued that the proposal constitutes "unfair discrimination," claiming that the "politically popular" decision to favor retirees over financial institutions would only result in "costly litigation that will hamper the city's emergence from bankruptcy."

The one group that may feel placated are the police and fire department retirees, who are slated to receive 90% of the money owed them (or 96% if they approve the plan early). These retirees' pensions are higher on average than other Detroit city workers, says Michelle Wilde Anderson at the UC Berkeley School of Law. Just the same, police and fire department retirees have been among the most vocal dissenters to the proposal. The Police and Fire Retirement System Board of Trustees issued a release calling the cuts and the failure to take cost of living or inflation into account "debilitating and unnecessary." The statement continued, "the City of Detroit can afford much better treatment of its pension beneficiaries who dedicated years of their lives in service of the city."

MORE: Is Wal-Mart serious about boosting the minimum wage? Don't bet on it.

So, who has a genuine grievance, and who's posturing? The answer is a little of both, on all sides. Every creditor has a legitimate claim to Detroit's money. The problem is that with $18 billion in debt and precious little in revenue from a dwindling tax base, there's not enough of it to go around. Cue a no-holds-barred assault from all sides for every penny.

With the latest plan, retiree funds "certainly have the most reason to be happy," says Wayne State University law professor Laura Bartell. But they're not out of the woods in terms of legal challenges from other creditors. It's a bigger problem when you consider retirees are the ones with the least ability to pay. With the average payout at less than $30,000, "these are not rich pensions," Bartell says.

Even worse than the proposed pension cuts, though, is the blow to health care benefits. In the plan, all pensioners who are eligible would be switched to Medicare, and those who are not eligible would receive a stipend that could be used to purchase a plan through the Affordable Care Act. Retiree groups say the stipend falls far short of what would be required to receive comparable care to what they receive under their current pension plans.

Detroit's restructuring is being watched closely by both bond markets and other distressed municipalities' public sector unions. Bartell thinks bond markets won't react too dramatically to the haircut and that Detroit will still be able to borrow at affordable rates in the future. After all, post-bankruptcy, the city's financial situation will only have improved.

As for pensioners, Detroit's plan to pay them will be hard for other cities to replicate: Right now, a substantial chunk of the funds for pensions will actually come from nonprofits and the state, and it will be tied to the preservation of the Detroit Institute of Arts. Nicknamed the grand bargain, the tactic is "basically a strategy to draw external charitable dollars into Detroit," Anderson writes in an e-mail.

MORE: Fed transcripts: Bernanke chose to let Lehman fail

If the plan succeeds in some form, and Detroit emerges from Chapter 9 this year, city officials are hoping that the fresh financial start will be enough to jump-start Motor City's long-awaited comeback. Free of mountains of debt and with a promising new mayor and $1.5 billion slated for improvements, a turnaround looks more realistic than it has in years.

That's cold comfort for cash-strapped retirees who depend on slim pensions. But in a city with outstanding obligations that easily exceed the GDP of Jamaica, they may be forced to take what they can get. Considering Detroit's history of financial wreckage, says Bartell, "this is a pretty good deal."

  • The new Fiat Chrysler faces a rougher road than most think

    Now that Fiat owns all of its American partner, the new company is officially on the hook for the $5.5 billion shortfall in Chrysler's pension funds.

    FORTUNE -- Sergio Marchionne, Fiat's chief executive, is an even bigger corporate cowboy than he seems to be. Not only is he trying to combine two smallish, debt-laden auto companies from two separate continents into a single efficient global giant, which is an enormous gamble, MORE

    - Feb 5, 2014 5:00 AM ET
  • Uncle Sam? More like Uncle Bernie if one group gets its way

    A plan that could stiff Social Security recipients to pay down U.S. debt isn't just stupid. It's downright Madoffian.

    FORTUNE -- Do you think it would be a good idea for the federal government to act like Bernie Madoff? To take money from people for decades, only to say, "Sorry, I'm out of cash," when it comes time to pay them what they're owed?

    It's hard to imagine anyone who would think MORE

    - Sep 27, 2013 5:00 AM ET
  • The problem with Obama's retirement proposal (redux)

    If it's fair to limit taxpayers' expense for retirement money being set aside by "the rich," it's vastly more fair to limit taxpayers' expense for Obama's own package.

    FORTUNE -- It's a lot of fun to be able to make what you think are clear, simple points about the difference between what people in power propose for the likes of you and me, and what they get for themselves.

    But every once MORE

    - May 10, 2013 5:00 AM ET
  • Mayor Edwin Lee on San Fran's pension problem and keeping Twitter in town

    Interview by Adam Lashinsky, senior editor at large

    FORTUNE -- One of the problems San Francisco interim Mayor Edwin Lee inherited when he took over for now Lt. Gov. Gavin Newsom was the city's underfunded pension system (see: San Francisco's Pension Smackdown). Backed by billionaire venture capitalist Michael Moritz, San Francisco Public Defender Jeff Adachi has been pressing an independent initiative to require public employees to contribute more to their pension plans. Labor MORE

    Jun 3, 2011 11:42 AM ET
  • Next up on the bailout list: The mailman?

    What did we learn from the bailouts of 2008 and 2009? Very little, based on what we're now seeing with the U.S. Postal Service.

    By James Hamilton, Econbrowser

    The challenge of meeting pension payments is starting to put a huge burden on the San Diego and California budgets, leading many of us to regret that more voices weren't raised in objection at the time these commitments were quietly made years ago. For MORE

    May 18, 2011 1:43 PM ET
  • Hedge fund returns won't save public pensions

    State pension funds are putting more of their money into higher risk investments like hedge funds, private equity, real estate, and commodities. But it won't fix their problems.

    As most everyone knows (and as politicians and public workers in Wisconsin, New Jersey, and New York are acutely aware) state and local pension funds could use some big investment paydays. The funds have pension and retiree healthcare obligations that they can't afford MORE

    - Mar 30, 2011 12:19 PM ET
  • Pension pain off the charts

    Big company pension funds are in their worst shape in at least 15 years, thanks in no small part to falling interest rates.

    So says Bank of America Merrill Lynch, which issued a report Friday estimating the aggregate pension funding deficit at S&P 500 companies at $380 billion. That's up 44% from a year ago and represents a funding gap of almost 3% of the index's market capitalization.

    The average defined benefit MORE

    - Oct 29, 2010 12:56 PM ET
    Posted in: , , ,
  • Fitch sees corporate pension timebomb

    Low interest rates could leave U.S. companies scrambling to cover huge pension shortfalls, Fitch warned Monday.

    The rating agency noted that the manic bond rally has benefited big issuers such as IBM (IBM) and Johnson & Johnson (JNJ), both of which were able to sell debt this month at record low yields. But the flip side of tumbling rates, Fitch analyst Mark Oline warns, is a fall in likely investment returns.

    A drop in MORE

    - Aug 23, 2010 2:07 PM ET
    Posted in: ,
  • May meltdown singes pension funds

    May's stock market selloff was predictably unhelpful for retirement savers.

    The market decline wiped more than 4 percentage points off the typical corporate pension plan's funding status, Bank of New York Mellon said. The decline leaves the average program 82% funded – its lowest level since last October.

    As recently as March, when stocks were still rising and credit spreads were tightening, pensions were 88% funded, the company said.

    "May's results wiped out MORE

    - Jun 4, 2010 11:18 AM ET
    Posted in: ,
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.