Deflating Europe: Is the European Central Bank finally ready to do its job?

March 28, 2014: 11:13 AM ET

Plagued by the persistent threat of deflation, the European Central Bank is considering bringing out the big guns.


FORTUNE -- If you thought central banks around the world were finally ready to give their printing presses a rest, think again.

In interviews this week with the Wall Street Journal, central bankers from Germany and Finland said that they would be open to the possibility to more aggressive monetary policy, including a full-blown quantitative easing program like the one the U.S. Federal Reserve is in the process of winding down.

The Fed launched its first round of quantitative easing way back in 2008. Since around that time, Europe has been dealing with an ongoing debt crisis. So why are the Europeans just now talking about these measures? A few reasons:

  1. 1. Unlike the Fed, the European Central Bank has a single mandate: Keep prices stable. Since the Fed is also tasked by Congress with maximizing employment, it had a much greater motivation to resort to unconventional ways to stimulate the economy;
  2. 2. The ECB is actually struggling to "keep prices stable." The thing is, the European Union is in danger of failing on the side of deflation; and
  3. 3. The American bond-buying program, which has successfully kept down long-term interest rates and has likely been at least a small boon to economic growth, has not lead to inflation as critics had feared.

MORE: Is Ben Sherwood the next Jeff Zucker?

Reasons 1 and 3 give the EU cover to pursue quantitative easing as a cure for 2. Even a little deflation is viewed by some economists as potentially worse than high inflation. Indeed this view is the official perspective in much of the world, as most central banks have explicit policy goals of maintaining yearly positive inflation of 1% or 2%.

What's so bad about deflation, you ask? Just as with inflation, there are good and bad varieties. In the case of inflation, if prices are rising rapidly because of the normal dynamics of supply and demand, well, that's just capitalism. But if prices are rising because of poor management of the money supply, that's a potentially destabilizing and self-enforcing crisis. The same goes for deflation: Prices fall all the time because of increases in productivity, and that's a sign of economic progress. But sometimes deflation attacks simply because in a weak economy, people become risk-averse. They stop spending money, causing prices to fall. This dynamic of falling prices hurts debtors, who have borrowed money at one price level, and are now seeing their incomes fall but their debt levels remain the same. And this dynamic can cause a series of defaults, which only makes the situation worse.

MORE: Billions of reasons for taxpayers to love Ally's IPO

The European Central Bank certainly doesn't want to see this situation occur, and so officials, even hawkish ones like Jens Weidmann, the German Bundesbank president, are saying that a European QE is a possibility.

Doesn't the EU already have a bond buying program of its own? Yes, to help quell the European debt crisis, the central bank began buying bonds of the weaker European economies, but unlike the U.S., it "sterilized" those purchases by selling other assets at the same time to keep the overall level of money in the system level. A full-scale quantitative easing program would forgo this step.

But hawks like Weidmann are quick to point out that a QE program might be considered illegal according to EU law, which bans so-called debt monetization, whereby government spending is financed by central bank money-printing. This is the sort of thing that has accompanied various episodes of hyperinflation from Germany in the 1930s to Argentina in the the 1980s. The problem with this phobia is that monetization is a symptom of hyperinflation rather than the cause. As Matthew O'Brien at The Atlantic has convincingly argued, hyperinflation is really triggered by some sort of exogenous calamity, like natural disasters or war, which destroys an economy's productive capabilities. It's when governments try to step in to repair this damage and rebuild the economy with printing and borrowing that hyperinflation really takes hold.

MORE: California teachers still own Bushmaster rifle maker

In fact, debt monetization is really just another word for the job of central banks. Central banks buy and sell government debt all the time in order to effect the right level of money in the system, depending on the economic conditions on the ground. And if you're worried about the wrong kind of deflation, there's not enough money in the system. And it's looking like the European Central bank might finally be realizing this is the case.

  • It's too early for the Fed to raise rates

    Raising interest rates would spell trouble for job-seekers.

    By Josh Bivens

    FORTUNE -- In her first press conference this week, incoming U.S. Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen indicated the central bank would reduce its bond purchases at a slightly quicker pace but also continued to de-emphasize the importance of the previously announced threshold of a 6.5% unemployment rate for raising short-term interest rates. Her remarks initially rattled markets, but this is MORE

    Mar 21, 2014 3:29 PM ET
  • El-Erian: Why Wall Street initially misread Janet Yellen

    In her first press conference, the U.S. Federal Reserve chair said the economy still requires extraordinary support, but wary investors looked elsewhere.

    By Mohamed A. El-Erian

    FORTUNE -- Headlines about Janet Yellen are less about substance and more about short-term miscommunication between the Fed and markets.

    "Yellen Debut Rattles Markets" is just one of the headlines that suggested that Janet Yellen, the new chair of the Federal Reserve, made some surprising policy MORE

    Mar 21, 2014 8:07 AM ET
  • Emerging markets turmoil: Quit overreacting

    Despite the recent sell-off of emerging market currencies, investors should look at the bigger picture

    By Dan Steinbock

    FORTUNE – For years, the market mantra was that emerging markets represented future growth. Lately, however, investors have pulled record levels of capital out of economies from Brazil to India. This is an overreaction; too many investors and analysts are focusing on short-term fluctuations rather than keeping their eye on emerging markets' longer-term prospects.

    Though the sell-off has eased, emerging market funds experienced MORE

    Feb 27, 2014 9:07 AM ET
  • Bernanke is driving the car but can't see the road

    The Federal Reserve appears over-optimistic in its economic forecast.

    By Mohamed A. El-Erian

    FORTUNE -- Last week, Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke used a simple car analogy to convey what the central bank may do going forward. Rather than tap the brakes, the Fed would ease a little on the accelerator; and it would do so only if economic conditions strengthened sufficiently.

    By distinguishing in this way between the brakes and the accelerator, MORE

    Jun 28, 2013 10:26 AM ET
  • Why I'm betting on a return to normal markets

    AQR Capital's Cliff Asness, who runs one of the world's biggest hedge fund firms, says now is not the time to freak out.

    FORTUNE -- No black swans here.

    That's the opinion of hedge fund manager Cliff Asness, who runs AQR Capital, which is one of the industry's biggest firms with $80 billion under management. The rapid move up in interest rates and the recent 800-point two-day drop in the Dow Jones MORE

    - Jun 27, 2013 10:51 AM ET
  • Fed's Bernanke talk tab: $151 billion and counting

    Holding $3.3 trillion in bonds when debt prices are falling might end up costing taxpayers money, or, then again, maybe not.

    FORTUNE -- Think your 401(k) has suffered in the stock and bond market rout? Consider the Federal Reserve's recent woe: By Fortune's estimates, the U.S. central bank has lost at least $151 billion in the past seven weeks. And counting.

    Economists both inside and out of the Fed have long suspected MORE

    - Jun 26, 2013 5:00 AM ET
  • The next Fed chief should run it like a business

    The Fed does not need an economist to run it. Perhaps it needs someone able to meet operating budgets.

    By Moshe Silver, Hedgeye

    FORTUNE -- Scientists observing bird flight patterns tell us the lead goose in the migratory V-pattern switches back and forth between looking ahead and looking back. It constantly checks the formation behind and adjusts its position to make sure it remains at the point of the flock. Periodically, the lead MORE

    Jun 25, 2013 10:56 AM ET
  • Teflon Bernanke?

    Yes, yes, people hate the Fed. But believe it or not, they're sort of OK with Ben Bernanke.

    So discovered Bloomberg news last week in conducting a poll of a thousand Americans.

    Of those surveyed, 39% said they believe the Fed's independence should be reduced and 16% said the central bank should be abolished altogether. Republicans in Congress are talking about eliminating the Fed's statuory responsibility for maintaining employment -- just so MORE

    - Dec 9, 2010 10:09 AM ET
    Posted in: , , ,
  • China's risky inflation offensive

    One central bank is sticking to its exit strategy, but hang on tight: Even optimists don't expect the ride to be silky smooth.

    China said Friday it will pursue a "prudent" monetary policy next year, after three years of aggressive money printing in the name of counteracting the global economic downturn.

    Jokes about the apparent contrast with Fed policy aside, the move shows the world's fastest-growing economy is shuddering at the prospect of MORE

    - Dec 3, 2010 11:43 AM ET
    Posted in: , , , ,
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by WordPress.com VIP.