FORTUNE -- Citigroup may be getting itself into more trouble.
In the past week or so, Citi has reportedly been indicating it may not reach a return on tangible common equity -- a key metric for investors -- of 10% by 2015. Citi (C) CEO Michael Corbat publicly set that target in a speech a little over a year ago, his first major presentation since taking the reins at the bank. Now, Citi has reportedly been telling some investors in private conversations that that 10% is no longer doable.
That might seem like a good public relations strategy -- announce an ambitious target as publicly as possible, and tell people you are going to miss it as quietly as possible. It may also be against the rules.
Since 2000, the Securities and Exchange Commission has barred companies from sharing news (good or bad) to certain investors or analysts before others. The rule is called Regulation FD, for fair disclosure. Recently, the rule nearly ensnared Netflix CEO Reed Hastings for a tweet. The SEC eventually let Hastings off the hook.
"Sounds like the kind of thing that Reg FD was specifically trying to correct," says Duke Law professor Jim Cox, who specializes in corporate and securities law. "Citi is walking a delicate wire."
Citi's shares are down 7% in the past two weeks, around the time the bank is likely to have started telling investors that it would miss its target. It's also around the time the Federal Reserve rejected Citi's proposal to increase its buyback and dividend. Shortly, after that, according to the Wall Street Journal, Citi's investor relations team started telling certain shareholders to lower their expectations, particularly for the bank's return on equity.
Publicly, though, the bank hasn't said anything about revising its ROE target. In a press release after the stress test, Corbat said, "We will continue to work incredibly hard to serve our clients and generate the returns our shareholders expect and deserve." In early March, Citi CFO John Gerspach reiterated that the bank was headed for an ROE of 10% "or higher," but Gerspach said getting there would require stock buybacks in future years.
A Citi spokesman says the bank had clearly conditioned its return target on its ability to buyback stock and pay dividends. "It is completely appropriate to point to these prior public statements in response to questions from investors," says the spokesman.
Shortly after the stress test, CLSA analyst Michael Mayo, who follows Citi, lowered his return target on the bank to 9%. But Mayo says he did it on his own. No one from the bank called him. "Citi clearly stated their assumptions, and buybacks were part of them," Mayo says.
Charles Peabody, a bank analyst at Portales Partners, also has said that it's unlikely Citi would make return targets. Peabody also says he came to that conclusion without any guidance from Citi.
Other analysts seem less certain. Veteran bank analyst Richard Bove of Rafferty Capital says the fact that Citi won't reach its target is news to him. On Wednesday, analysts at Barclays put out a research note in which they said they were waiting to hear if Citi would alter its ROTCE (return on tangible common equity) target.
Duke's Cox says the fact that Citi has tied its return target to buybacks in the past, or that analysts have come to the same conclusion independently, may not let the bank off the hook with Reg FD. He says the "truth in the market" defense has never been tried and "I would guess it wouldn't be successful."
He says having one-off communications with investors could be a red flag to the SEC that Citi could have been conveying new information. Cox says if Citi wanted to lower its ROE expectations it should have put that out in a press release or a filing.
The good news for Citi is that in the nearly 10-and-a-half years since Reg FD has been on the books, the SEC has brought few cases based on it.
You could also argue that Citi's ROE isn't material. Citi investor Tom Kahn of Kahn Brothers says he didn't get a call from Citi investor relations about a change in the ROE target and hasn't called to find out. "It's meaningless," says Kahn. "Corbat is doing an excellent job, and the stock is cheap."
More important than any disclosure gaffe could be Citi's performance in general. A year after Corbat set the 10% goal, Citi isn't much closer to getting there. The company's return on tangible common equity was 8.2% in 2013.
"What they are saying is that they can't grow their business as fast as their book value," says Bove. "That's an incredible statement, and it's new to me."
Are private equity firms ripping off their own investors?
FORTUNE -- Reuters reported yesterday that the Securities and Exchange Commission has formed a "dedicated group to examine private equity and hedge funds." Also yesterday, Bloomberg reported that the SEC completed a review that found "a majority of private equity firms inflate fees and expenses charged to companies in which they hold stakes."
The two revelations are being closely watched by private equity firms, MOREDan Primack - Apr 8, 2014 2:48 PM ET
A civil complaint filed in federal court in Missouri Thursday accuses JPMorgan of allowing the Millennium Bank Ponzi scheme to operate right under its nose.
FORTUNE -- The ghosts of financial crises past continue to haunt JPMorgan.
Just months after the bank settled with federal authorities over allegations that it turned a blind eye to Ponzi-schemer Bernie Madoff, the bank is facing fresh accusations that it failed to do anything about yet MOREChristopher Matthews - Mar 14, 2014 2:01 PM ET
Latest charges offer more evidence that the case against Steven A. Cohen is winding down.
FORTUNE -- Ronald Dennis will likely be the last person from SAC Capital to be charged with insider trading.
On Thursday afternoon, the Securities and Exchange Commission alleged that Dennis, while working as an analyst at SAC Capital and an affiliate firm, made or avoided losses of $3.75 million for the firm by trading on MOREStephen Gandel, senior editor - Mar 13, 2014 5:39 PM ET
It may seem awkward, but is there anything actually wrong with a hedge fund manager bankrolling an all-out assault on a company?
Correction: March 10, 4:45 PM.
FORTUNE -- Bill Ackman really, really wants to prove that Herbalife is a fraud. That's not new. What's new is the lengths he is apparently going to to convince everyone, particularly regulators, that he is right.
On Monday, the New York Times detailed those efforts in MOREStephen Gandel, senior editor - Mar 10, 2014 2:59 PM ET
The New York District Attorney drops the hammer on the team who led Dewey & LeBoeuf into the largest law firm bankruptcy ever.
By Allan Dodds Frank
FORTUNE -- The New York District Attorney Thursday charged that the top three former leaders of the now defunct international law firm Dewey & LeBoeuf engaged in a massive criminal conspiracy for nearly four years to cover up the firm's financial condition before it MOREMar 6, 2014 3:54 PM ET
The nation's top stock market cop needs a better compliance policy.
FORTUNE -- Here's a twist in the government's recent crackdown on insider selling: One of the main regulators tasked with policing the illegal practice may be instructing its employees to do just that.
Securities and Exchange Commission employees regularly sell shares of companies in their personal portfolios that come under investigation by the agency before those investigations become public. Indeed, in MOREStephen Gandel, senior editor - Mar 4, 2014 1:33 PM ET
Compared to the SEC, it's incredibly unlikely JPMorgan has had a shortage of financial experts capable of detecting Madoff's Ponzi scheme. The bank received several red flags but they went nowhere.Nin-Hai Tseng, Writer - Jan 8, 2014 5:00 AM ET
Stephen Cutler says bank regulations and fines are getting out of control.
Clarification: 11/22, 5:40 PM
FORTUNE -- Apparently, JPMorgan Chase's top lawyer has some hurt feelings over his bank's recent $13 billion fine.
Stephen Cutler, speaking Friday morning at an industry conference, fired back at the government and said that the regulation of banks is spiraling out of control. He said regulators are wasting taxpayers' resources by piling on infractions and issuing MOREStephen Gandel, senior editor - Nov 22, 2013 2:39 PM ET
The SEC issues rules on equity crowdfunding. What took it so long?
FORTUNE -- The current Securities and Exchange Commission chair has the same first name as her predecessor. But one clear difference between Mary Jo White (new) and Mary Schapiro (old) is that the former actually cares about doing her job.
Today the SEC formally proposed rules on equity crowdfunding, a mechanism through which private companies would be able to raise small MOREDan Primack - Oct 23, 2013 1:52 PM ET
|5 people you might not tip (but should)|
|Will millennials kill Costco?|
|Nonprofits that pay top fundraisers $1 million (or more) a year|
|Pope Francis challenges the free market - The Buzz|
|Stocks: It's report card time on Wall Street|