Sheila Bair

Sheila Bair: It's time for a European FDIC

March 20, 2013: 10:14 AM ET

The Cyprus banking crisis underscores the crucial need for Europe to put standardized rules in place for the protection of insured depositors.

cyprus-protests

By Sheila Bair

FORTUNE -- In Greek mythology, Cyprus was the birthplace of Aphrodite, the Goddess of Love, and surrogate mother of Adonis, the God of Desire, who was an avid hunter. A typical overbearing mother, Aphrodite warned Adonis never to hunt an animal that showed no fear. A a typical know-it-all son, Adonis ignored his mother's warning. He pursued an enormous (and fearless) boar. But the hunter quickly became the hunted, and he was brutally killed by the wild animal.

Up until Monday morning of this week, bank depositors in the troubled Eurozone were looking as fearless as the boar. They were keeping faith in their national deposit insurance schemes, even in southern European countries with significant fiscal problems. Though last summer, there had been a spate of "bank trots" in Spain, Greece, and Italy, for the most part depositors seemed to trust the legal commitments their sovereigns had given them to protect their savings. They stayed put.

In fact, the surprising confidence bank depositors exhibited in national deposit insurance schemes slowed momentum to create a central deposit guarantee system (DGS) in the Eurozone to provide consistent coverage with the collective backing of all Eurozone countries. Progress on creating a single resolution mechanism for handling failing banks also slowed down.

MORE: El-Erian: Why Europe bungled another rescue

But then government officials in Cyprus, a tiny country with big banking problems, decided to hunt the boar, going after depositors below the 100,000 Euro deposit limit with a 6.75% "assessment" to help bailout their troubled banking industry. This was apparently done to reduce haircuts on large depositors who exceeded the limit, many of whom are reported to be rich Russians who use Cyprus banks to avoid paying taxes.

The boar charged. Street protests ensued and markets dropped, amid widespread speculation that this proposal would shake confidence in deposit insurance systems throughout southern Europe and beyond, precipitating massive bank runs. Unlike Adonis, the Cyprus parliament had the wisdom to retreat quickly and rejected the plan.

Those involved in concocting this fiasco included the IMF and European finance ministers. What in the world were they thinking? If there has been one constant throughout the financial crisis and its aftermath, it is that imposing losses on insured depositors was off-limits. Unfortunately, the Armani suits and dresses around the Cyprus bailout negotiating table lost all perspective when it came to protecting the backbone of any banking system--household depositors.

Elites in the financial media sniveled that it shouldn't be a big deal that some of the little folk had to pay. Some actually hinted that it might be a good thing. Maybe those schoolteachers and policemen would learn a thing or two by taking losses on their bank accounts and start exercising a little market discipline in deciding where to deposit their money. Instead of relying on deposit insurance schemes, they should be going home at night and downloading and analyzing banks financial reports. (Curiously, they didn't seem too bothered by the bailout of institutional bondholders who presumably are a little better equipped to evaluate bank balance sheets.)

MORE: Bank run expert: Cyprus' plan was 'absurd'

Appeased, the boar has retreated. The markets have calmed down a bit, pending Cyprus' next move, and protesting depositors have returned to their homes. But this never should have happened. It only underscores the crucial need for Europe to put standardized rules in place for the protection of insured depositors and the allocation of losses for their troubled banks.

A claims priority is not hard to construct. Here's how we do it in the US: equity gets wiped out first, followed by junior debt, senior debt, and deposits above the insurance limits. Insured depositors always get paid with losses covered out of reserves built from insurance premiums paid by the industry. We don't protect bondholders for two very good reasons: 1) there is no insurance program for them and they shouldn't get a free ride and 2) they are mostly sophisticated institutions that should be exercising market discipline and analyzing a bank's health before deciding to buy its debt. Whether this priority makes sense for Europe is something Europe can decide for itself. The important thing is to decide. The ad hoc way Europeans are making decisions is creating unfairness and uncertainty in the way bank creditors are treated and impeding their banking system's recovery.

And for heaven's sake, would Europe please create a strong, centralized deposit insurance authority to stand up for household depositors the next time some blockhead decides they might be an easy, economically vulnerable target when putting a bailout package together? There is a reason that the U.S. hasn't suffered a bank run since the Great Depression and it is called the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. Europe needs an FDIC, and they need it badly.

Posted in:
  • My new year's resolution? To kick my savings habit

    With interest rates in the basement, why keep squirreling all that money away? Let's take out some loans and rack up some debt!

    By Sheila Bair, contributor

    FORTUNE -- It's well into the new year. Have you made your resolutions yet? No? Well, I have a suggestion. This just could be the year the economy comes roaring back. The housing market is up; unemployment is down. But we all need to MORE

    Jan 25, 2013 5:00 AM ET
  • Why Republicans need to help Obama

    A little Democratic idealism mixed with some old-fashioned fiscal discipline could be what Republicans need to get Americans back on their side.

    By Sheila Bair, contributor

    FORTUNE -- Over the past four years income inequality has worsened, particularly among minority groups. Continuing a long-term trend, the gap between rich and poor is the widest it has been in 40 years. Wealth inequality is even more skewed, with the upper classes enjoying MORE

    Dec 19, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • Why aren't big banks issuing more long-term debt?

    Many banks are thinking more about maximizing short-term profits than about building a stable base of funding that will protect them when interest rates inevitably rise again.

    By Sheila Bair

    FORTUNE -- During the financial crisis, several large financial institutions heavily relied on short-term borrowings to support their operations. This became a major problem. As credit markets froze, the banks were unable to renew their expiring short-term loans and thus were MORE

    Dec 4, 2012 6:59 AM ET
    Posted in:
  • 4 ways Wall Street can ante up for fiscal health

    Wall Street chiefs say they want Washington to come up with a long-term fix for our debt problems. How far are they willing to go?

    By Sheila Bair

    FORTUNE -- Okay everyone, listen up. I'm going to say something nice about Wall Street CEOs. That is because they are putting their considerable political clout behind a cause that benefits the rest of us: getting our fiscal house in order with a long-term, MORE

    Nov 19, 2012 10:30 AM ET
    Posted in:
  • Want to fix Congress? Let's institute pay for performance

    It's helped make corporate America run better.  It might just be the ticket to get our lawmakers back on track.

    By Sheila Bair, contributor

    FORTUNE -- Will the elections bring about improvements in our increasingly dysfunctional government? I fear not. Successfully running for office these days is more about political fundraising and negative campaigning than about the art of governing. Only one in 10 Americans thinks Congress is doing a good MORE

    Nov 6, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • Sheila Bair: 5 questions for the candidates on finance reform

    No one wants to see another financial crisis, so let's ask both Mitt Romney and Barack Obama some very pointed questions about how they would prevent it.

    By Sheila Bair

    FORTUNE -- The economy has taken center stage in the drama of the 2012 Presidential race. Yet, neither candidate's campaign script acknowledges the connection between our current economic woes and the financial crisis which caused them. Four years after the crisis, MORE

    Oct 16, 2012 5:00 AM ET
    Posted in:
  • Dear next President: Court your adversaries

    The next President will need to raise the bar on how the White House reaches out to adversaries, according to a bipartisan panel at Fortune's Most Powerful Women conference.

    By Tory Newmyer, writer

    FORTUNE -- President Obama would need to work much harder reaching out to unfriendly power centers in a second term. That was the striking point of bipartisan consensus from former George W. Bush adviser Karen Hughes and Obama bundler Mellody MORE

    Oct 3, 2012 4:10 PM ET
  • Sheila Bair and the bailout bank titans

    As the financial system melted down in the fall of 2008, the Treasury Department gave the nation's biggest banks billions in new capital. Was it all necessary? No, says the former FDIC chief in her new book.

    By Sheila Bair, contributor

    FORTUNE -- Few players had as close a view of the financial crisis as Sheila Bair, chairman of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. from June 2006 to July 2011. In MORE

    Sep 20, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • Libor and the folly of deregulation

    The New York Fed dropped the ball during the Libor scandal.  Could it happen again?

    By Sheila Bair, contributor

    FORTUNE – A lot of fingers are pointing in a lot of directions in the Libor price-fixing affair. Tim Geithner is pointing his finger at the Bank of England. Republicans in Congress are pointing their fingers at Geithner. The big banks are pointing their fingers at one another. But one party to MORE

    Aug 17, 2012 5:00 AM ET
About This Author
Sheila Bair
Sheila Bair
Contributor, Fortune

Sheila Bair is a Fortune contributor, and a former chair of the FDIC, and former member of the Basel Committee. She is also the author of the New York Times bestseller Bull by the Horns, Fighting to Save Main Street from Wall Street and Wall Street from Itself.

Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by WordPress.com VIP.