A new arrest at an SAC fund brings the government closer to Steve Cohen's door. Now might be a good time to become a family office in order to avoid future scrutiny.
FORTUNE -- The past few days haven't been kind to Steve Cohen, founder of the mega-hedge fund SAC Capital.
On Thursday, a judge decided not to approve his firm's settlement of insider trading charges with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
A day later, Michael Steinberg, a top portfolio manager at an SAC fund, was arrested and charged with securities fraud. The criminal indictment reignited speculation that the government is trying to nail Cohen for insider trading, and it forced the firm to yet again remind the world that Cohen is innocent until proven otherwise.
"Steve Cohen has not been charged with any wrongdoing and has done nothing wrong," a spokesman for SAC said.
Be that as it may, investors seem concerned about the ongoing government investigations at SAC and the fact that arrests of current and former employees have averaged about one a quarter for the past few years. In February, a source close to SAC told CNNMoney and others that it lost about $1.7 billion to redemptions. A month earlier, SAC was expecting redemptions of just $1 billion.
Investors left despite the fact that Cohen is still making money. His firm gained about 13% in 2012, and this year it's up more than 4% as of mid-March, according to a person close to the firm. And another round of redemptions is expected in May.
The client defections mean that about 70% of SAC's assets under management come from within the firm, and the bulk of that amount is Cohen's own capital. Given these numbers, one wonders why the billionaire hedge fund manager doesn't just return money to investors and run SAC as a so-called family office.
Such a move could lessen the public scrutiny on Cohen, says Ron Geffner, a partner at law firm Sadis & Goldberg who specializes in structuring, organizing. and counseling hedge funds and other investment advisors. "A manager who returns money and is no longer accepting new investments theoretically has no obligation to communicate any factual information regarding ongoing investigations," he says.
With the government continuing to probe SAC and related hedge funds, Cohen has reportedly discussed these matters on group calls and in private conversations with his investors. That has fanned worries that the insider trading investigations could be a distraction for portfolio managers at SAC.
And it's possible that ongoing investigations could deeply damage Cohen's firm and reputation, even if he is never found guilty. Pequot Capital, which like SAC had reached $15 billion in assets under management, shuttered in 2009 amid years of insider trading probes. "Public disclosures about the continuing investigation have cast a cloud over the firm and have become a source of personal distraction," Pequot founder Arthur Samburg wrote in a letter to investors. "I have concluded that Pequot can no longer stay in business." Samburg, who settled with the government, was never found guilty of insider trading.
Many high profile managers have recently closed funds to outside investors, including George Soros, Stanley Druckenmiller, and Carl Icahn. While none of them were under investigation, each felt that the world had changed dramatically -- new regulations, saturated markets, a radically different hedge fund landscape -- and that those changes made it too difficult to operate as they once had.
Of course, turning SAC into a family office doesn't mean that prosecutors can't still try to take assets from employees or investors. "The government can try to claw back profits if they deem that they were gained through violative activity," says Geffner.
And Cohen's dilemma is far different from that of a Soros and Druckenmiller. By closing their firms, they no longer had to deal with the things that made running a hedge fund difficult. With or without outside money, regulators will still be eyeing Cohen and his firm.
So while turning SAC into a family office could help in some respects, one attorney said that it would be sending the wrong message. If Cohen is innocent, he should continue to accept money from outside investors. "Why should the terms of his firm be dictated by others?" says Stuart Slotnick, a securities lawyer who specializes in white collar crime. "Notwithstanding all the rumor and innuendo, he's still running a successful business."
Hedge fund affiliates of SAC Capital will pay more than $600 million.
FORTUNE -- Regulators announced Friday that affiliates of the hedge fund SAC Capital had settled insider trading charges for more than $600 million. While the amount is stunning -- with one settlement touted by the Securities and Exchange Commission as "the largest ever in an insider trading case" -- some believe that this could actually be a positive development for MOREKatie Benner - Mar 15, 2013 5:59 PM ET
After falling down hard in the run-up to the financial crisis, regulators are hoping to stage a comeback with a wide-ranging insider trading probe. But as investigators circle Steve Cohen and SAC Capital, the government risks losing what little crime-fighting credibility it has gained.
FORTUNE -- The public's desire to see someone, anyone, come down hard on Wall Street has been answered, not by Dodd Frank, but by U.S. attorney Preet Bharara and MOREKatie Benner - Jun 6, 2011 3:25 PM ET
The government investigation of Steve Cohen's firm has reportedly prompted a well-known investor to put in a redemption request. Will more follow?
FORTUNE -- Last week I wrote that investors were standing by their man Steve Cohen, despite the fact that government investigators and a prominent Congressman were probing his hedge fund firm, SAC Capital.
While there's still no wave of redemptions, Institutional Investor broke the news that an investor wants out of MOREKatie Benner - May 31, 2011 7:37 AM ET
But do investigators have the juice to snag the man that they have been circling for years?
FORTUNE -- With a massive victory against hedge fund titan Raj Rajaratnam in the rearview mirror, it seems like the government has turned its attention to its next big target.
I'm not talking about the trial that begins today against Zvi Goffer, a former Galleon employee who allegedly ran an insider trading ring of his own.
I'm talking about MOREKatie Benner - May 16, 2011 11:42 AM ET
Fund managers make ridiculous sums of money for the most obvious stock pick in history: Apple. Is this the best Wall Street has to offer?
Blame for the credit crisis has been doled out liberally. Depending on your particular persuasion, it was all the fault of Wall Street, greedy homeowners, lazy ratings agencies, Chinese currency manipulators, bad regulation, bad regulators, or shady mortgage types. The cohort that hasn't gotten its fair MOREDuff McDonald, Contributing Editor - Feb 25, 2011 8:30 AM ET
How would YOU defend yourself from insider trading charges? You can go the Raj Rajaratnam route or the Steve Cohen one. I'd take the latter.
If a man is known by the company he keeps (or has kept), then these are tough times, reputationally speaking, for hedge fund kingpins Raj Rajaratnam and Steve Cohen. While neither has been convicted of a crime, hardly a day goes by in which we MOREDuff McDonald, Contributing Editor - Feb 2, 2011 11:10 AM ET
The consultant at the center of the FBI's insider trading probe has grabbed the microphone and won't let go. Is it an amateur move? Or a brilliant one?
Sometimes, it's difficult to figure out the motive behind people's actions. Take Julian Assange, for example. Is he actually an anarchist? Or just a wannabe playboy? It's hard to say. Maybe he's both.
Then there's John Kinnucan, heretofore-unknown technology researcher and current toast MOREDuff McDonald, Contributing Editor - Dec 10, 2010 5:00 AM ET
He's the man with the bulls-eye on his head, yet the Feds can't quite seem to hit it. It's beginning to look like it's riskier to be associated with the hedge fund giant than it is to be Steve Cohen himself.
Last week's flurry of news about a massive investigation into insider trading by hedge funds had Wall Street asking its favorite recurring question: Are they finally going to get MOREDuff McDonald, Contributing Editor - Dec 3, 2010 10:44 AM ET
Just as all roads lead to Rome, all insider trading investigations lead to SAC Capital's Steve Cohen. He can't shake the Feds because he's too good to be true.
When word got out that FBI agents raided three hedge funds on Monday in the ever-expanding insider trading investigation—Level Global Investors, Diamondback Capital Management, and Loch Capital Management—it didn't take long to connect the dots to the person that all of Wall MOREDuff McDonald, Contributing Editor - Nov 23, 2010 3:10 PM ET
|Chrysler relents, agrees to recall 2.7 million Jeeps|
|Google files First Amendment court case against NSA surveillance secrecy|
|Immigration bill could cut deficits by $175 billion - CBO|
|China's fastest-growing cities for millionaires|
|It's official: Jack Lew's new signature|