TARP
The government is still trying to say the bailouts made money
May 21, 2012: 1:59 PM ETHere's one instance where you should give the Treasury an "F" for effort.
Correction: 5/24 12:57
FORTUNE -- A few weeks ago the Treasury Department put out its latest report of what the government's rescue efforts in the wake of the financial crisis cost taxpayers. The conclusion: Nada. In fact, the Treasury says that if you take a broad view of all the bailout programs, taxpayers actually are looking at a $9 billion profit. It is the government's latest effort to paint the bailouts as a win-win for everyone. And like others it's clearly wrong.
Gretchen Morgenson does a pretty good job of taking on the report in this weekend's New York Times. In order to get to its $9 billion profit, the government includes in its calculations the $179 billion gain that the Federal Reserve made during the financial crisis. But at least a portion of the Fed's profits are interest payments on U.S. government debt, which the Fed has been buying to drive down interest rates. Those payments, of course, are paid by the government. So calling that a net gain is silly.
But Morgenson misses the bigger point. Ever since the bailouts, the government has been trying to cut the data in ways to make the bailouts seem profitable. In the past they have tried to focus on the bank bailouts alone, saying they made $10 billion. But that ignores the bailouts of the auto companies, which cost $22 billion. Other times the government has said that taxpayers have received all of their money back from the bailout of the nation's largest banks. But that ignores the 351 small and community banks that owe $15 billion to the government, and according to TARP inspector general Christy Romero have no real ability to ever pay that back.
In the latest report, the government excludes its foreclosure prevention programs. That seems odd for a report that the government says is its broadest look ever at its response to the financial crisis. Foreclosures, afterall, were at the heart of the problem. But that may make sense for the government's accounting: Add in the mortgage modification efforts, and the government's bailout efforts swing to a $51 billion loss.
The problem with this type of accounting of the bailouts is that politically it's not realistic. When the government starts handing out assistance, it's nearly impossible politically to stop with the biggest banks. Indeed, Occupy Wall Street and others are still pushing to get the government to do more for struggling homeowners and others. It's likely Uncle Sam eventually will.
In the end, it seems odd that the Obama administration would want to stick with this idea that the bailouts were profitable. It seems to undercut their argument that there is a need for financial reform, and to rein in Wall Street and prevent future bailouts. That's something that everyone seems to agree on. Everyone hates bailouts. I say we leave it that way.
Correction: I was wrong to say that the Treasury's cost analysis of the government's financial rescue efforts didn't include home loan modification programs. It does. Even with the program the government can claim that it made money on the bailouts, as long as you include the Fed's transfers, which I am not sure you should. I should have also mentioned that Fortune has covered this ground before. Our earlier analysis backs up the claim that the government made money on the bailout efforts. What's more, I am sorry for the delayed correction, but I waited to talk to the Sigtarp's office to get their analysis of the bailout efforts, because in part that's supposed to be their job. The Sigtarp's main beef appears to be that Treasury is counting shares the Federal Reserve got from AIG to offset losses that the Treasury had on its AIG investment. That tripped me up as well. But it really wasn't part of what I wrote here, which was wrong. In the recent words of Jamie Dimon and Robert Greifeld, this was not my finest hour.
-
American Idiots: How Washington is destroying the economy
What's ailing us? It's not just unemployment. It's not just Europe's debt woes. And, no, it's not Wall Street this time. It's the takeover of the economic debate by fanatics who are up to no good. Fix that -- and maybe you fix the economy.
FORTUNE -- What the hell is going on?
Standard & Poor's, the bond-rating agency, downgrades the U.S., and the world trembles. The markets here go nuts on MORE
Allan Sloan, senior editor-at-large - Aug 18, 2011 5:00 AM ET -
Allan Sloan's bad math and bad analysis
An outside critique of our analysis: "Surprise! The big bad bailout is paying off"
By Bob Eisenbeis, Cumberland Advisors
A recent column by Allan Sloan and Doris Burke in the Washington Post claims that the distasteful financial bailout not only worked but also generated a profit for the government of at least $40 billion and perhaps as much as $100 billion. Their conclusion is based on their working of the numbers, and the MORE
Jul 19, 2011 5:00 AM ET -
Surprise! We still believe the big bad bailout is paying off
Our recent analysis of the U.S. bailout caused quite a ruckus. Here is our response to the critics who say we omitted some key details.
FORTUNE -- When we wrote our story about the financial-system bailout turning a profit for taxpayers, my Fortune colleague Doris Burke and I (and our editors) decided that less was more. So we showed you our bailout numbers, but didn't give you much detail about how MORE
Allan Sloan, senior editor-at-large - Jul 19, 2011 5:00 AM ET -
It's time for a European TARP
Investors are in panic mode over the debt crisis in parts of Europe, and they're demanding swift, sweeping action by European financial leaders to reverse its Lehman moment. Eurobonds, anyone?
By Cyrus Sanati, contributor
FORTUNE -- Investors are pushing the panic button as the European debt crisis spins out of control. Banks around the world are trying to calm their clients' fears, setting up special conference calls and one-on-one sessions, but there MORE
Jul 15, 2011 8:45 AM ETPosted in: Credit Suisse, Eurobond, European Financial Stability Facility, European Union, Greece, Macro, TARP -
Surprise! The big bad bailout is paying off
The U.S. government's often maligned $14 trillion intervention not only staved off global collapse - but is making money.
With Doris Burke
FORTUNE -- The bailout of the financial system is roughly as popular as Wall Street bonuses, the federal budget deficit, or LeBron James in a Cleveland sports bar. You hear over and over that the bailout was a disaster, it cost taxpayers a fortune, we didn't really need it, it MORE
Allan Sloan, senior editor-at-large - Jul 8, 2011 5:00 AM ET -
How to lose friends in Washington: Be TARP cop
Until last week, Neil Barofsky was the special investigator of the TARP program, where he says his main job duty was blunting the effects of the Treasury's bad decisions.
FORTUNE -- Neil Barofsky has been chasing bad guys for much of his professional career. Whether it was as an assistant US Attorney in the Southern District of New York or in his most recent gig as the man trying to make MORE
Duff McDonald, Contributing Editor - Apr 5, 2011 9:40 AM ETPosted in: Banking, FDIC, Neil Barofsky, Sheila Bair, sigtarp, TARP, Tim Geithner, treasury, Troubled Asset Relief Program -
TARP deadbeat list hits 142: update
The TARP deadbeat list continues to grow.
The number of banks missing scheduled quarterly dividend payments to the government hit 142 last month, according to the latest Treasury report on the subject. That's up from 123 in November, 115 in August and 91 in May, SNL Financial said.
The delinquent banks have $3.7 billion of government loans outstanding, SNL said. The list of the late banks is available from Treasury here, starting MORE
Colin Barr - Mar 16, 2011 12:03 PM ET -
Why AIG stock is both up and down
AIG has had some strange days, but today may take the cake.
Shares in the big insurer traded around $44 Thursday. That's way down from Wednesday's close of $51.02. Yet the quote services correctly show AIG (AIG) shares up 3%. What gives?
The answer is that until this morning, AIG shares were trading attached to a right to receive part of a warrant to buy additional AIG shares. That right came about when MORE
Colin Barr - Jan 20, 2011 11:56 AM ET -
TARP deadbeat list hits new high
The stock market isn't alone in hitting new highs this week. So is the list of TARP deadbeats.
A grand total of 123 banks failed to make their Nov. 15 dividend payments on Troubled Asset Relief Program loans, SNL Financial reports. That's up from 115 institutions that deferred their August payments.
The report comes as the estimated cost of the bailout program continues to fall, and as Treasury is raking in billions MORE
Colin Barr - Dec 15, 2010 1:00 PM ET
