taxes
Zell's legacy lives on: IRS goes after Tribune
June 18, 2013: 9:00 AM ETBy the time the final papers are shuffled, the IRS and local tax authorities are likely to seek more than half a billion dollars from Tribune in regard to the sales of the Chicago Cubs and Newsday under former CEO Sam Zell.
Sam Zell
FORTUNE -- Sam Zell is gone from the Tribune Co., but his toxic financial legacy lives on. Not only did his debt-fueled purchase of one of the nation's biggest media companies help precipitate its bankruptcy, costing creditors billions and wiping out thousands of jobs, but he has left a nasty tax mess behind for Tribune, which exited Chapter 11 proceedings on Dec. 31.
As I predicted several years ago, the Internal Revenue Service has challenged the tacky tax-avoiding way that Zell had Tribune unload Newsday, a Long Island, N.Y. newspaper, and it seems virtually certain to challenge the way that Tribune unloaded the Chicago Cubs.
By the time the final papers are shuffled, the IRS and local tax authorities are likely to be seeking considerably more than half a billion dollars in taxes, penalties, and interest from Tribune in regard to what I call the "non-sale sales" of the Cubs and Newsday.
Before we proceed, a bow to tax expert Bob Willens of Robert Willens LLC, who told his clients that he expected both the Cubs and the Newsday deal to be challenged.
Willens's newsletter reported Monday that the IRS had rejected the tax treatment Tribune had sought for the Newsday deal. This led me to a Tribune financial report that was issued Monday. Guess what? Buried in the tax footnotes, Tribune (which declined comment) said that the IRS is seeking $190 million of taxes and a $38 million "accuracy-related penalty" for not treating the 2008 Newsday transaction as a sale. In addition, Tribune said, it could be liable for $17 million of interest to the IRS, and $28 million of taxes and interest to other taxing authorities. Total exposure: $273 million.
MORE: Introducing: The kid VC
Tribune also said that its return for 2009, the year it unloaded the Cubs, is being audited, and a challenge to the Cubs deal could cost $225 million plus interest and penalties. Apply the same penalties as the IRS is seeking in the Newsday deal, and the total exposure is about $300 million.
In its tax footnote, Tribune says that it "disagrees with the IRS position (about Newsday) and will request that the IRS administrative appeals office review the issue." That would explain why Tribune says it had no reserves set aside for Cubs or Newsday-related tax liability.
I find this amazingly optimistic on Tribune's part, considering how gamy the transactions were. In the Newsday transaction, Zell -- who boasts about his tax-avoiding skills at every opportunity -- had Tribune contribute Newsday to a partnership to which Cablevision (CVC), the big Long Island cable TV outfit, contributed $650 million of promissory notes. Tribune emerged with $630 million in cash. Cablevision emerged with 97.14529% of Newsday. And somehow, we -- and the IRS -- were supposed to believe this wasn't a sale.
Zell played a similar game with the Cubs, contributing the team to a partnership with the Ricketts family of TD Ameritrade fame, which contributed $740 million. Tribune (TRBAA) emerged with $705 million, the Ricketts family emerged with 95% of the Cubs.
MORE: Ben Bernanke threatens private equity
These deals smelled so awful that when they were made, Bob Willens was telling his clients he expected the IRS to challenge them. That's now happened with the Newsday deal, and seems to be on tap for the Cubs deal.
I used to have a reasonably congenial relationship with Zell, who named himself the Gravedancer because he specialized in buying distressed properties that had been left for dead. I even ended up as a minor character in an artwork he commissioned to commemorate a 1992 tax-avoiding deal. He placed me in the lowest circle of hell and purposely misspelled my name.
I used to consider Zell and his tax avoidance schemes sort of amusing. But the amusement -- and congeniality -- are both long gone.
I'm sure that after litigation or the threat of it, Tribune will ultimately settle considerably less than the $600 million likely total of the claims, penalties and interest. However, my bet is that Tribune will ultimately fork over more than $100 million to pay for the tax games Zell played with Newsday (one of my former employers) and the Cubs.
That's just what the company, struggling to survive in a hostile landscape for media companies, needed in its new life -- a big, fat tax bill from the past. Thanks a lot, Sam.
-
Got a Swiss bank account? Time to fess up.
Now that Switzerland has agreed to cooperate with a broad U.S. tax evasion probe, thousands of wealthy American account holders may soon be exposed to the IRS.
By Lynnley Browning
FORTUNE -- Are you among the suspected tens of thousands of Americans with a secret Swiss bank account that you are still hiding from the Internal Revenue Service? If so, you are about to acquire a Matterhorn-sized headache.
Switzerland made a desperate MORE
May 30, 2013 5:00 AM ET -
What's missing from tax reform debate: A level playing field
Businesses organized as partnerships account for 35% of all sales. So why are we taxing them at higher rates than other corporations?
By Stephen Chipman and Doreen Griffith
FORTUNE -- The top concern for certain business entities seeking to compete on a level playing field through tax reform has not yet been addressed.
Ways and Means Chairman Dave Camp has released a tax reform discussion draft that would simplify the tax rules for MORE
May 14, 2013 12:44 PM ET -
U.S. citizens ditch passports in record numbers
If the recent quarter's pace continues, 2013 will become a landmark year for saying goodbye to America, tax-wise.
By Lynnley Browning
FORTUNE -- Americans are ditching their U.S. passports in record numbers, a sign of growing frustration with a system that taxes U.S. citizens on their global wealth whether they live in Montana or Mongolia.
The latest bold-faced names to relinquish their U.S. citizenship include Mahmood Karzai, a brother of Hamid Karzai, MORE
May 8, 2013 1:35 PM ET -
Obama has a sweet retirement package. Will you?
No one says the President doesn't deserve his benefits. But it's hard to get past his plan to limit savers to half the value of what he'll walk away with.
FORTUNE -- President Obama's proposal to limit the value of 401(k)s, pensions, and other tax-favored retirement accounts to about $3.4 million certainly sounds reasonable. After all, at a time of big budget deficits, we shouldn't subsidize "the rich" with tax breaks, MORE
Allan Sloan, senior editor-at-large - May 1, 2013 5:00 AM ET -
Offshore account holders win a victory in government tax case
The Justice Department got a black eye last week in a case involving a 79-year old Florida widow with $43 million in offshore accounts.
By Lynnley Browning
FORTUNE -- Federal judges usually dislike tax evaders, and in recent years they have imposed hefty fines, lengthy probation, and even prison sentences on dozens of Americans with offshore bank accounts. But the watershed case of Mary Estelle Curran, a 79-year-old widow who earned MORE
Apr 29, 2013 2:33 PM ET -
AXA's private equity spin-out slowed by French tax debate
Tax worries delayed spin-out of $31 billion investment group.
FORTUNE -- French insurance giant AXA Group today reached an agreement to spin out its $31 billion private equity unit, a whopping 18 months after originally putting the unit up for sale. Part of the delay apparently related to uncertainty over new tax schemes being proposed by French President Francois Hollande.
The entire deal values AXA Private Equity at €510 million, and includes MORE
Dan Primack - Mar 22, 2013 2:59 PM ET -
Billionaires should beware of Puerto Rico
The beaches are inviting, but Puerto Rico's political risks and its high crime rate should make wealthy tax-dodging Americans think twice before moving.
By Cyrus Sanati
FORTUNE -- John Paulson and other plutocrats should think twice before moving to Puerto Rico in search of a tax break. While the Caribbean Island's recent push to lure wealthy individuals from the U.S. mainland seems like a great deal, there is no guarantee that MORE
Mar 12, 2013 10:31 AM ET -
The hidden tax Washington doesn't want you to know
Two new charges may not affect middle-class taxpayers now, but left unchecked, they will.
FORTUNE -- Okay, middle-class taxpayers: Listen up. Our national government in Washington is screwing you again. This time the screwing involves the way that two new income tax surcharges, supposedly designed to affect only the "rich," will reach deeper and deeper into the middle class unless something is done now to rein them in.
I'm talking about the MORE
Allan Sloan, senior editor-at-large - Feb 27, 2013 5:00 AM ET -
Dell's tax dodge?
Dell's buyout won't free its 'trapped' foreign cash.
FORTUNE -- Dell Inc. has approximately $11 billion of cash "trapped" overseas. And now some folks think that the company's $24.4 billion buyout will help it bring some of that cash stateside without tax consequences. They are wrong.
Here is the basic argument for claiming the Dell (DELL) buyout is, in the words of Slate's Matt Yglesias, "essentially a large-scale tax-avoidance scheme."
Dell is going MORE
Dan Primack - Feb 6, 2013 3:38 PM ET
