The labor market had a groundhog day.
FORTUNE -- Different report, same numbers.
Squint at January's job numbers and you might think you are looking at the stories from a month ago. Employers added 157,000. The initial report from December was 155,000. (It has since been revised up.) Unemployment rate: 7.9%. In December: 7.8%.
At the start 0f 2012, the unemployment rate was falling pretty rapidly. In the four month period from October 2011 to last January, the unemployment rate fell from 8.9% to 8.3%. But now the unemployment rate has stalled.
Why? First of all, there are more people entering the workforce than there were a year ago. About 1.6 million people in 2012. That's a good thing. More people are optimistic they will find work. But with more people looking, it's harder for the unemployment rate to fall further unless people actually get hired.
At some point you begin to ask if we are ever going to have a real recovery. The consensus estimate for U.S. economic growth this year is 2.3%. That number roughly translates to a job gain of about 125,000 jobs a month. That's basically just enough to provide jobs for the number of people entering the workforce each month. Not much extra for the unemployed.
What's more, at least some of the boost we got in 2012 came from a housing rebound. But that could be coming to an end. Refinancing activity, which had put more money in peoples' pockets to spend, appears to be slowing. Mortgage rates have climbed a bit recently. Economist and housing expert Robert Shiller says the big jumps we have recently seen in prices in Las Vegas and Phoenix and other areas hard hit from the foreclosure crisis, are likely to be short lived.
Even if they aren't, most housing sales are likely to be in existing homes, as underwater borrowers and banks finally unload unwanted properties. Real jobs gains in housing always come from construction, which is still employing 2 million fewer workers than before the recession.
The same can be said for the stock market. Last year, stocks rose 14%. And that makes everyone feel wealthier and better about the economy. But with earnings growth slowing it's hard to see how the market continues to climb higher.
Then of course, there is Washington, which still appears to be more focused on reducing the deficit than getting people back to work. Add in Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke's cheap money policies, which at some point have to be reversed, and it's no wonder that economists surveyed by CNNMoney think the unemployment rate will end the year at 7.5% -- just a little bit lower than where we are now.
The signs that the job market is not as good as it seems are fading.
FORTUNE -- It's time to stop the yeah, buts.
Ever since the unemployment rate began falling two and a half years ago, commentators have come up with reasons why the job market is not actually improving. The Labor Department reported that the job market had improved in February, with employers adding 227,000 workers to their payrolls. But MOREStephen Gandel, senior editor - Mar 9, 2012 2:48 PM ET
|Make $30 an hour, no bachelor's degree required|
|The 'chicken poop' credit and other bad tax breaks|
|McDonald's gives Charles Ramsey free food for a year|
|Investors consider life after Fed stimulus|
|Hedge fund guru says moms and trading don't mix|