wealth gap

Only the wealthy feel economic recovery

July 1, 2013: 5:00 AM ET

Recent data suggests the Fed may be misreading the strength of the average American consumer.

chart-same-store-salesFORTUNE -- One reason Ben Bernanke might be thinking it's time for the Federal Reserve to pull back on its stimulus efforts could be American consumers.

During a speech at the Council on Foreign Relations last week, Fed governor Jeremy Stein was asked where he sees economic growth coming from, and he said consumers were one of the main reasons he was optimistic. "Consumers generally seem to be showing some signs of strength."

They have seemed like a resilient lot. Despite a payroll tax increase, government furloughs, and the rest of the sequester cuts, consumers in general appear to be spending more this year. But that may be an illusion.

MORE: Prepare for a slowdown in the housing recovery

We got a glimpse of that last week. On Wednesday, the government said the economy grew 1.8% in the first quarter. That was down from an earlier estimate of 2.5%. The bulk of the reason for the revision was consumer spending. Americans didn't open their wallets as wide or as often as originally thought.

What's more, much of the spending was on big ticket items. In fact, take out a jump in spending on utilities, a quirk of a colder winter than a year ago, and purchases of everyday items, like meals, were nearly flat.

On Thursday, the government said consumer spending picked up in May but again showed a similar picture. Much of the increase in spending came from purchases of cars and home improvements. Take those out and there wasn't much growth.

Economist Dean Baker, of the Center for Economic and Policy Research, suspects what is really boosting the consumption numbers is not that the finances of average Americans have improved, but instead what we are seeing is a boost from the special dividends companies paid out at the end of last year, in order to avoid the tax hikes of the fiscal cliff. Those went mostly to wealthy Americans. The rising stock market has, too, mostly served to improve the finances of the more well-off. That may explain why big ticket items are rising faster than spending in general.

The concern is that the further we get away from when those dividends were paid out, along with the fact that the stock market has recently flattened out, the big increase in spending from wealthy Americans might subside as well.

MORE: Is J.C. Penny a better bet than gold?

Ken Perkins, who runs Retail Metrics, says luxury retailers have done better than other stores even since the early days of the recovery. But he says the gap between retailers like Tiffany (TIF) that cater to wealthy Americans and Target (TGT) has been growing this year. Perkins says Wal-Mart (WMT), for instance, has been adding more and more non-discretionary items into its store mix in an effort to boost sales.

"It speaks directly to the fact that Wal-Mart's customers don't have a lot of money to spend outside of household necessities," says Perkins.

For a while, when economists talked about consumer spending in this recovery, they talked about the barbell. Discount stores and luxury stores were doing well. Now the bar only seems to be bulging at one end, and even that might not last.

  • Stop beating up the rich

    Instead of taking them down, shouldn't we figure out how to lift everyone up?

    By Nina Easton, senior editor

    FORTUNE -- Alexis de Tocqueville famously chronicled American society's love of equality -- and its equally passionate pursuit of money. "The love of wealth," the French historian wrote in the 1840s, "is … at the bottom of all that the Americans do." America stands out among Western nations for its grudging, and MORE

    Sep 6, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • Not everyone hates the rich

    Before we start predicting a coming class warfare, keep in mind that Americans may dislike inequality, but they don't all blame the wealthy.

    By Nina Easton, senior editor-at-large

    FORTUNE -- After the 1987 stock market crash, the New York Times offered up a page-one obituary for a "gilded, impudent age," quoting great minds who predicted the demise of unbridled self-interest in America. Three short years later, when a recession marked the MORE

    Jun 7, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • Don't blame the 1% for America's pay gap

    It's time to end the myth that the nation's wealthy are getting rich off the backs of the poor. Instead let's figure out what they're doing right.

    By Nina Easton, senior editor-at-large

    FORTUNE -- What if I told you that there was a group of hard-driving workaholics who tend to have advanced degrees and bring a level of talent and skill to their jobs that attracts premium pay in the global MORE

    Apr 24, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • Politicians have no cure for the middle-class blues

    Obama and Romney each have a plan to lift Middle America from its rut, but election-year promises aren't going to fix an issue that's been brewing for decades.

    By Geoff Colvin, senior editor-at-large

    FORTUNE -- President Obama likes to say, "The 2012 election is a make-or-break moment for the middle class." He's mistaken -- it isn't. Mitt Romney likes to say, "This President and his policies have made it harder on the American MORE

    Mar 30, 2012 5:00 AM ET
  • Occupy Wall Street: Where's our share?

    FORTUNE -- Operation Occupy Wall Street, which started with a handful of protesters in New York City's Zuccotti Park on Sept. 17, has spread to scores of cities around the world and attracted hundreds of thousands. While the protesters in the U.S. haven't put forth a clear agenda, their growing numbers suggest that many Americans are unhappy with the economic status quo. --Anne VanderMey

    By the numbers:

    $300,000: The amount of money estimated MORE

    Oct 27, 2011 5:00 AM ET
  • What really has the 99% up in arms

    It's not that the rich are getting richer. It's that the rest of America isn't.

    By Geoff Colvin, senior editor-at-large

    FORTUNE -- The most important fact to realize about the rash of popular protests around the world -- Occupy Wall Street in the U.S., demonstrations in Greece, Spain, London, and elsewhere in Europe, violent uprisings in rural China, even the revolutions of the Arab Spring -- is that they aren't about money or MORE

    Oct 20, 2011 11:36 AM ET
Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by WordPress.com VIP.